The Unborn Child (2011) vs. Gosnell (2018)

Who wears a dress shirt to bed?
Who wears a dress shirt to bed?

Gimme an "A"! Gimme a "B"! Gimme an "O"...

Posted: Dec 8, 2018 4:52 PM
Updated: Dec 8, 2018 4:57 PM

Sex and violence are staples of American pop culture. When the two are combined in the form of abortion, however, the nation’s storytellers seem to develop a bit of stage fright. They either dance around the subject with the daintiness of a virgin spinster or tell the same two morality plays over and over. It’s either a tale of the misery faced by women who want abortions but can’t get them or the regret and discomfort caused when old abortions come to light. But for a subject that has roiled American politics for over half a century, there has been precious little entertainment which grappled with either the reality of or metaphysical questions posed by abortion.

This edition of KIMT’s Weekend Throwdown will consider two movies that approach the issue from each side. One is a foreign flick that mines its existential ugliness for some low-key horror thrills and the other is a crowd funded U.S. production that seems almost afraid of its unvarnished truth. It’s “The Unborn Child” (2011) vs. “Gosnell: The Trial of America’s Biggest Serial Killer” (2019) in a contest to see if horrible truths make the best horror movies.

Did her mother cut her hair with a broken bowl?

“The Unborn Child” is a film out of Thailand that claims to be based on a true story of a woman who claimed the ghost of her aborted baby was haunting her. So…”true” might be pushing a little. It follows the vaguely interconnected stories of a teenage couple who just got pregnant, a middle class professional couple with a young daughter, a hard-bitten abortionist and her baby-corpse disposing partner, and an actress facing a slumping career and an unwanted pregnancy. It’s one of those Asian ghost flicks where 90% of the action revolves around the characters reacting to scary sounds and something standing behind them that only the audience can see.

Presenting us with a Thailand where abortion is heavily restricted and even more heavily stigmatized, there are elements of “The Unborn Child” that will be strikingly pro-choice to American eyes. It is brutally honest about the awful dilemma facing young women who get pregnant before they are ready and the even more awful lengths they will go to free themselves from that maternal burden. The black market abortion practices displayed in this movie are more horrifying in their implication than a thousand gallons of fake blood and viscera. No one of good conscience would ever want a woman to have to go through that.

I think I know where the guys who did the CGI for "Lara Croft: Tomb Raider" wound up.

Yet “The Unborn Child” also endorses in no uncertain terms that abortion is as much an anathema to traditional Buddhist morality as it is to traditional Christian teaching, showing it as the taking of innocent life and justifying the supernatural revenge of its victims. The abortionist and her undertaker partner are clearly defined as evil but neither is portrayed as inhuman, particularly when we see their rationalizations and excuses shatter when they are confronted with the magnitude of what they have done.

What is more interesting about “The Unborn Child” is how it demonstrates the power of cultural imperialism. It shows us four different levels of Thai society. There’s the high school kids who have no money or resources of their own. There’s the working class nature of the abortionist and the undertaker. There’s the middle class success of married professionals. And then there’s the actress living the lifestyle of the still rich and famous. What’s fascinating is that the higher you move up the socio-economic ladder, the more Americanized the characters become. The poorer characters look and talk and dress like they’re from a foreign land, but the richer characters would fit in fine in San Francisco or Des Moines. Though they’re the same nationality, they might as well be from different worlds.

"What kind of a gumball machine did THIS come out of?"

For its part, “Gosnell” may be one of the most disturbing non-horror flicks ever made. It’s a story that touches one electrifying issues after another, from race and sex to exploitation and willful blindness to atrocities, yet the producers had to LITERALLY go begging for money to make it. Hollywood just made a second big screen version of “The Grinch Who Stole Christmas,” the umpteenth version of Robin Hood, a remake of “Papillon,” and a film about the 1970s tennis rivalry of John McEnroe and Bjorn Borg. But a black doctor in inner city Philadelphia who was accused of not only killing an adult patient through medical incompetence but of murdering possibly thousands of babies after they were born alive? NO ONE in show business thought that would be a movie worth making?

Based far more faithfully on the actually true story of Kermit Gosnell, this motion picture is surprisingly restrained given its subject matter. I mean, a medical zealot killing scores of innocent children over decades while letting his medical office and home turn into something out of the TV show “Hoarders?” It’s like if “The Texas Chainsaw Massacre” actually happened. But this movie goes out of its way to avoid visual excesses or gross emotional manipulations. Partly, I’m sure that’s because they didn’t have the budget for anything too fancy. But I believe the tone of this film is mostly a deliberate decision to approach it more as an historical document than sensationalized propaganda. It is entirely accurate to say the investigation, arrest, and trial of Kermit Gosnell is something that mainstream American media and American popular culture wanted very much to ignore. Just go see the difference in results from your favorite search engine between “Kermit Gosnell” and “George Tiller.” The people behind this motion picture wanted to be sure this story wouldn’t be flushed down the memory hole.

And somewhere, Bill Cosby breathes a sign of relief that he's no longer the kindly old black guy with the worst secret life.

But I also suspect the makers of “Gosnell” were a little afraid of pushing things too far. This is perhaps the biggest, wettest, and reddest bloody shirt the pro-life movement could ever wave and I think the filmmakers avoided being as explicit as they could, even when presenting the pure and unadulterated truth, because they feared the backlash. Not just having a film business and media go from refusing to distribute, promote, or talk about “Gosnell” to actively trying to destroy the careers of everyone involved with it. I would guess they were also concerned a movie that makes “The Passion of the Christ” look like romantic comedy starring Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks would not appeal to the folks most interested in the film’s inescapable message.

Nick Searcy's look when someone suggested his next film be about the founder of the North America Man/Boy Love Assocation.

“The Unborn Child” takes a long time to get to its big ending, which is then slightly spoiled by CGI effects which look like they were cooked up on somebody’s old Commodore 64. That makes it easy to give this Throwdown to “Gosnell,” which is quite nicely done by everyone involved. But I think they both go a long way toward showing why abortion isn’t such fertile ground for horror flicks and why TV and cinema keep recycling the same safe and predictable abortion plots over and over again. I mean, it’s not like there are a bunch of horror movies about the Holocaust…are there?

The unwritten rule for all cop partners...always color coordinate!

The Unborn Child (2011)
Written by Poj Arnon and Thanadon Nuansutthi.
Starring Somchai Kemgland, Pitchanart Sakakorn, Chinaradi Anupongphichart, Chudapha Chanthakhet, Peerawit Boonark, Arisara Thongborisut, and Gathinda Chaang.

Gosnell: The Trial of America’s Biggest Serial Killer (2018)
Written by Andrew Klavan, Ann McElhinney, and Phelim McAleer.
Directed by Nick Searcy.
Starring Dean Cain, Sarah Jane Morris, Nick Searcy, Michael Beach, Cyrina Fiallo, Earl Billings, Janine Turner, Paula Jay Fairbrother, and Alfonzo Rachel

Dagny Taggart?

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 490011

Reported Deaths: 6618
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin1016821593
Ramsey43388811
Dakota36714394
Anoka33545392
Washington22247262
Stearns18847202
St. Louis14915265
Scott13445107
Wright12635116
Olmsted1187890
Sherburne879474
Carver790941
Clay696288
Rice678691
Blue Earth604435
Kandiyohi582274
Crow Wing523682
Chisago502945
Otter Tail487171
Benton451890
Winona419749
Mower411931
Douglas395068
Goodhue390169
Nobles387347
Polk345363
McLeod341950
Beltrami339151
Morrison328147
Itasca315346
Becker315143
Lyon314045
Isanti310056
Steele304311
Carlton300649
Freeborn287124
Pine283616
Nicollet263341
Todd250330
Brown249137
Le Sueur238620
Mille Lacs230047
Cass221424
Waseca211217
Meeker208534
Martin190829
Wabasha18733
Roseau181017
Hubbard161041
Houston158214
Dodge15464
Renville152940
Redwood147127
Fillmore14029
Pennington139816
Chippewa137035
Cottonwood136120
Wadena131520
Faribault125017
Aitkin119233
Sibley118310
Watonwan11838
Rock116314
Kanabec109120
Pipestone101924
Yellow Medicine97817
Murray9548
Jackson94710
Swift87818
Pope8185
Marshall78715
Stevens7478
Lake74318
Clearwater72014
Lac qui Parle68816
Wilkin67711
Koochiching62111
Big Stone5173
Lincoln5122
Grant4928
Norman4808
Unassigned45368
Mahnomen4437
Kittson41121
Red Lake3615
Traverse3115
Lake of the Woods2231
Cook1190

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 337836

Reported Deaths: 5500
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk52116562
Linn19519317
Scott17180213
Black Hawk14973294
Woodbury13858214
Johnson1317875
Dubuque12452196
Dallas1023593
Pottawattamie9899146
Story965445
Warren515176
Clinton502884
Cerro Gordo501483
Webster495888
Sioux480469
Marshall465473
Des Moines428661
Muscatine426493
Buena Vista413337
Wapello4059110
Jasper388167
Plymouth369178
Lee354653
Marion341772
Jones285355
Henry279837
Bremer270655
Carroll266848
Crawford253435
Boone244830
Benton241554
Washington239247
Mahaska215846
Jackson210339
Dickinson204340
Tama203165
Kossuth198655
Delaware186340
Clay184525
Winneshiek183729
Fayette179535
Page178119
Buchanan178029
Wright174531
Hamilton173942
Cedar172923
Hardin170339
Harrison167870
Clayton160154
Butler159331
Mills148520
Floyd148141
Poweshiek148030
Cherokee146336
Lyon145741
Allamakee144948
Madison143318
Iowa140723
Hancock138030
Grundy132530
Winnebago130531
Calhoun129711
Cass129751
Jefferson128534
Appanoose123447
Louisa122644
Mitchell120740
Chickasaw119915
Union119331
Sac118818
Shelby117634
Emmet115440
Humboldt113925
Franklin109719
Guthrie109728
Palo Alto101721
Howard99722
Unassigned9790
Montgomery97036
Clarke95220
Keokuk92429
Monroe90028
Ida82132
Adair81630
Pocahontas80919
Davis76623
Monona76527
Greene73110
Lucas72321
Osceola68315
Worth6678
Taylor64112
Decatur5719
Fremont5619
Van Buren53818
Ringgold50720
Audubon4769
Wayne47521
Adams3194
Rochester/St. Mary'S
Clear
59° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 33°
Feels Like: 59°
Mason City
Clear
61° wxIcon
Hi: 61° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 61°
Albert Lea
Partly Cloudy
55° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 55°
Austin
Partly Cloudy
55° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 32°
Feels Like: 55°
Charles City
Partly Cloudy
59° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 59°
Prepare for a warmer but breezier Tuesday
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Latest Video

Image

Sean's Weather 3/8

Image

Rochester NAACP President calls for accountability

Image

Rochester's Diversity Council talks racial inequality

Image

Mary Kristin Scott PKG

Image

Tailgate service

Image

Fewer babies being born

Image

Sara's Sunday Night Forecast

Image

Blooming Prairie GBB PKG

Image

Sara's Saturday Night Forecast

Image

Olmsted County Fair asks for help from lawmakers

Community Events