BREAKING NEWS Mason City man arrested in connection to loud booms heard throughout town Full Story
STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Iowa surrogacy case headed to U.S. Supreme Court

Woman argues surrogacy contracts violate the rights of mothers and babies.

Posted: Jul 5, 2018 4:18 PM

DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — An Iowa woman is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to consider striking down surrogacy contracts as a violation of the constitutional rights of mothers and their babies.

In an appeal of a February Iowa Supreme Court ruling, a Muscatine woman is asking the nation's highest court to take the case and hear arguments and then find that a surrogate mother does not waive her constitutional rights and those of her future child when she signs an agreement to have a baby for another couple.

The woman, identified in court documents only as T.B., is challenging a ruling that concluded for the first time in Iowa that gestational surrogacy agreements are enforceable. The Iowa court said banning such arrangements would deprive infertile couples of perhaps the only way to raise their own biological children. The court ruling meant the woman was legally not the parent of the now-23-month-old girl to whom she gave birth.

Gestational surrogacy is the practice of a woman agreeing to take payment to have a baby for a couple using eggs and sperm from the intended parents or donors. The birth mother is not biologically related to the baby. Several courts have found only individuals biologically tied to the baby are the legal guardians and custodians. Several states, including Iowa, California, New Hampshire, Virginia, and Washington, have laws that prevent women from asserting these protections after signing surrogacy contracts.

The surrogate mother's attorney, Harold Cassidy, filed an appeal application to the U.S. Supreme Court in May, and on Tuesday the attorney for the Iowa couple who have raised the girl since her birth, Paul and Chantele Montover, filed an objection to the court taking the case.

The court is likely to decide this fall whether to consider it and hear further arguments.

Cassidy said the woman isn't seeking custody of the child, but wants to have some sort of a relationship with her. He said the goal of the case is to help protect other women and children going forward.

Cassidy argues that children have a right "to be free from commodification and sale" and mothers have a right to be free from "state promoted and state-enforced exploitation." He equated surrogacy agreements to "slavery or involuntary servitude."

"A minority of states enforce these contracts, but before this goes any further the courts need to review the constitutional issues both in respect to the rights of the children and with respect to the rights of the mother," Cassidy said. "It's been a long time since we declared we're not going to enforce or adhere or sanction the buying and selling of a human being of any kind, yet that's what this is."

Casey Rigdon, the Montovers' attorney, argued in court filings that the Supreme Court should reject the case because it "has never protected the alleged relationship between gestational carrier and the child she delivers."

He said the surrogate mother cites no federal law or precedent that even suggests traditional protection of this sort of relationship. He also argued that the woman entered the contract voluntarily and was fully informed.

Iowa, like many states, has no clear law on surrogacy parenting, but a 1989 Iowa law making it a felony to sell an individual to another person specifically exempts surrogate mother arrangements. The Iowa court interpreted that as legislative intent to allow such agreements.

The woman reached an agreement with the Montovers to have a baby for them after reading their Craigslist advertisement in 2016. The Montovers had decided at age 50 that they wanted to raise a child together. They agreed to pay the woman $13,000 to have a baby using an egg from an unknown donor and Paul Montover's sperm.

After the relationship between the Montovers, who are white, and the surrogate mother, who is black, deteriorated to the point at which she said she and her husband were called racial epithets, the woman decided to reject payment and keep the infant.

The baby was 2-months-old and still in the hospital being treated for medical complications related to her premature delivery when a judge awarded Paul Montover custody. The Iowa Supreme Court ruling this year gave the Montovers permanent custody.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 91422

Reported Deaths: 2031
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hennepin26147923
Ramsey10595318
Dakota7250125
Anoka5836132
Stearns383324
Washington362755
Scott247333
Olmsted232927
Nobles193816
Blue Earth16166
Wright15497
St. Louis141936
Carver13657
Rice13098
Mower13015
Clay128840
Sherburne110914
Kandiyohi9362
Winona85318
Lyon6554
Waseca5508
Freeborn5263
Steele5262
Benton5173
Nicollet51316
Watonwan5114
Todd4812
Chisago4621
McLeod4612
Le Sueur4464
Crow Wing44418
Otter Tail4024
Beltrami3805
Martin34310
Goodhue3409
Itasca28913
Pine2870
Polk2774
Isanti2680
Douglas2672
Becker2512
Carlton2461
Unassigned22052
Cottonwood2190
Pipestone21510
Morrison2131
Dodge2090
Chippewa1981
Meeker1872
Sibley1873
Brown1812
Wabasha1810
Yellow Medicine1622
Rock1590
Murray1552
Mille Lacs1523
Redwood1441
Jackson1361
Renville1367
Cass1343
Faribault1330
Swift1231
Roseau1170
Houston1150
Kanabec1148
Pennington1131
Fillmore1100
Koochiching1103
Lincoln1030
Stevens931
Pope890
Hubbard851
Aitkin761
Big Stone710
Wadena670
Grant594
Wilkin573
Lake560
Norman520
Marshall501
Lac qui Parle471
Mahnomen461
Red Lake381
Traverse300
Clearwater260
Lake of the Woods211
Kittson120
Cook60

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 81296

Reported Deaths: 1284
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Polk15404259
Woodbury506463
Johnson502827
Black Hawk439688
Linn3832108
Story334017
Dubuque289141
Scott283528
Dallas270038
Pottawattamie200638
Buena Vista195512
Marshall176434
Sioux14163
Wapello128057
Webster120914
Clinton108020
Muscatine107854
Plymouth106220
Crawford10215
Cerro Gordo100721
Warren9396
Jasper78332
Des Moines7477
Marion7345
Tama69531
Carroll6445
Henry6314
Lee6097
Wright5651
Dickinson4876
Boone4808
Bremer4717
Washington44011
Louisa42615
Mahaska35819
Delaware3493
Franklin34418
Hamilton3173
Jackson3103
Floyd3063
Winneshiek3045
Clay3014
Benton2921
Hardin2851
Winnebago27813
Lyon2694
Butler2632
Clarke2613
Poweshiek2588
Buchanan2551
Emmet25310
Allamakee2516
Jones2513
Shelby2501
Clayton2383
Kossuth2370
Guthrie2315
Cedar2261
Chickasaw2250
Sac2220
Cherokee2122
Grundy2103
Madison2072
Fayette2032
Iowa1931
Harrison1892
Howard1836
Mitchell1830
Humboldt1773
Calhoun1762
Hancock1762
Mills1681
Palo Alto1650
Pocahontas1542
Lucas1536
Monroe15110
Monona1421
Page1420
Cass1392
Osceola1390
Jefferson1341
Appanoose1263
Taylor1251
Union1233
Davis1184
Van Buren1111
Ida1050
Worth1030
Keokuk951
Greene940
Fremont900
Montgomery905
Wayne842
Audubon701
Adair681
Decatur630
Ringgold452
Adams290
Unassigned80
Rochester
Clear
80° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 80°
Mason City
Clear
80° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 80°
Albert Lea
Clear
81° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 81°
Austin
Clear
81° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 81°
Charles City
Clear
79° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 79°
Tracking more warmth before cooler weather arrives for the weekend
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Latest Video

Image

CDC issues new guidance for Halloween celebrations

Image

450 Prom dresses donated to Rochester church

Image

Trump sign getting looks in cornfield

Image

Minnesota House candidates square off during local forum

Image

Hy-Vee gives away 500 meals to Rochester families

Image

HyVee gives away 500 meals

Image

NIACC dealing with Covid-19 on a daily basis

Image

MN Statehouse candidates meet in forum

Image

Iowa voter registration day

Image

Tuesday's soccer highlights

Community Events