Is the Kerala temple battle about gender, law or religion? Unfortunately, all three

To call it big would be an understatement. On Tuesday, a ...

Posted: Jan 4, 2019 12:17 PM
Updated: Jan 4, 2019 12:17 PM

To call it big would be an understatement. On Tuesday, a human chain stretching for more than 600 kilometers (372 miles) was formed by millions of women in the southern Indian state of Kerala to demand entry to a major Hindu temple that traditionally barred women of child-bearing age.

It was the largest demonstration of its kind since the issue became a national talking point in September, when a ruling by India's Supreme Court scrapped the gender restriction, calling it unconstitutional.

Asia

Continents and regions

Demographic groups

Elections and campaigns

Females (demographic group)

Gender equality

Government and public administration

India

Narendra Modi

Political Figures - Intl

Politics

Population and demographics

Sex and gender issues

Society

South Asia

Belief, religion and spirituality

For months, attempts to enact that ruling had been thwarted, with female devotees blocked entry to the temple site by angry mobs.

That changed on Wednesday, when two women made history by slipping into the shrine before daybreak, flanked by plainclothes police deputed to protect them.

For many in India, however, this isn't only an issue of gender equality. The battle over who can and can't enter the Sabarimala temple is also a question of tradition and the limits of the law. And then there's the politics, as orthodox and secular forces clash ahead of India's general elections later this year.

Ever since the court handed down its order, advocates for gender equality -- both in and beyond Kerala -- have been calling for it to be implemented. They see the restriction on the entry of women between ages of 10 and 50 as one of the many vestiges of discrimination against women in India.

After the two women entered the shrine Wednesday, the temple was briefly closed by priests for "purification" rituals — a move that leading daily newspaper The Hindu said in an editorial published Friday, "invoked old and regressive notions of purity and pollution, of defilement and desecration."

But religious conservatives and their backers insist that, no, this isn't about gender equality -- it's about the limits of law. For them, the court had no business intervening in the issue, which they see as a matter of religion and faith.

It's a view endorsed by the country's Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, who leads the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party.

In an interview with the Indian news agency ANI published just a day before the two women entered the shrine, Modi cited the view of the lone female judge on the bench when the Supreme Court handed down its verdict in September, who dissented. "India is of one opinion that everyone should get justice. There are some temples, which have their own traditions, where men can't go," Modi said, coming down the side of those say this is ultimately a matter of faith and tradition.

To be sure, he's not alone. Other voices from across the political spectrum have echoed this line, including local and national leaders of the Congress, the principal opposition to Modi's BJP.

With India just months away from a general election, the issue has, perhaps inevitably, become more and more politicized, as national parties eye the votes of conservative Hindus who oppose the court's ruling.

Not everyone shares that view. The local communist politicians who govern Kerala state, from the Communist Party of India-Marxist, have backed the court order -- and helped organize the human chain protest.

Divisions over the issue have already turned fatal. A BJP supporter was killed during protests in Kerala's capital over the entry of the two women, as activists from the Prime Minister's party clashed with those allied with local communist leadership. Kerala remains tense, with security forces out in large numbers in an attempt to maintain peace.

And later this month, the argument returns to court, when Supreme Court judges review petitions calling on them to revisit their September ruling. The hearing is set for January 22.

Whatever they decide, one thing seems clear: Many people, on one or the other side of what's become an increasingly fractious public argument, will be left disappointed.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 63723

Reported Deaths: 1739
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hennepin20063845
Ramsey7904270
Dakota4670106
Anoka3891115
Stearns293520
Washington225548
Olmsted180923
Nobles17819
Scott166922
Mower11172
Rice10488
Blue Earth9606
Wright9395
Carver9153
Clay79540
Sherburne75810
Kandiyohi7251
St. Louis63620
Todd4312
Lyon4273
Watonwan3842
Freeborn3651
Nicollet36313
Steele3632
Benton3273
Winona27216
Beltrami2670
Crow Wing26514
McLeod2400
Le Sueur2371
Martin2125
Chisago2111
Otter Tail2094
Goodhue2089
Cottonwood1800
Becker1641
Pipestone1619
Polk1614
Waseca1571
Carlton1490
Itasca14612
Douglas1441
Unassigned14446
Isanti1410
Dodge1360
Pine1320
Murray1251
Chippewa1191
Morrison971
Wabasha970
Faribault930
Brown922
Rock890
Meeker882
Sibley862
Koochiching833
Jackson810
Cass793
Pennington751
Fillmore730
Mille Lacs733
Renville675
Lincoln610
Grant574
Swift571
Roseau530
Yellow Medicine530
Houston490
Pope480
Aitkin421
Norman400
Hubbard370
Kanabec372
Redwood370
Wilkin353
Marshall300
Wadena280
Mahnomen271
Big Stone250
Lake240
Red Lake240
Stevens220
Traverse150
Clearwater140
Lac qui Parle90
Lake of the Woods70
Cook60
Kittson30

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 51101

Reported Deaths: 965
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Polk10800210
Woodbury378354
Black Hawk324566
Linn250389
Johnson216521
Dallas195135
Scott180815
Buena Vista180112
Dubuque177031
Marshall147527
Pottawattamie140029
Story120315
Wapello94336
Muscatine88048
Webster8678
Crawford7433
Cerro Gordo67119
Sioux6713
Warren5972
Tama56129
Plymouth49312
Jasper49028
Wright4851
Clinton4504
Dickinson3874
Louisa37814
Washington30710
Boone2783
Franklin25912
Hamilton2561
Bremer2407
Des Moines2262
Clarke2103
Clay2101
Carroll2082
Emmet1974
Marion1930
Shelby1931
Hardin1890
Floyd1753
Jackson1671
Benton1641
Allamakee1624
Poweshiek1608
Henry1464
Mahaska14417
Guthrie1425
Lee1415
Buchanan1401
Cedar1361
Jones1362
Butler1332
Madison1302
Delaware1291
Humboldt1271
Hancock1252
Lyon1242
Pocahontas1202
Clayton1163
Harrison1161
Cherokee1101
Winnebago1080
Winneshiek1061
Kossuth1020
Page1010
Taylor1000
Iowa981
Palo Alto980
Fayette960
Mills951
Monona931
Calhoun922
Cass901
Jefferson890
Osceola880
Sac870
Grundy861
Mitchell830
Union831
Monroe758
Lucas744
Worth710
Chickasaw620
Davis622
Montgomery624
Howard550
Appanoose533
Fremont450
Greene420
Keokuk411
Van Buren391
Adair380
Ida330
Audubon301
Decatur280
Ringgold241
Wayne211
Adams170
Unassigned50
Rochester
Clear
59° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 59°
Mason City
Clear
61° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 61°
Albert Lea
Clear
63° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 63°
Austin
63° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 63°
Charles City
Clear
61° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 61°
Sever storm chances return for Friday night
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Latest Video

Image

Marching Band makes adjustments for Covid-19

Image

Virtual Wing Ding for Democrats in Iowa

Image

Improving Relations Between Law Enforcement and Communities

Image

Gov. Walz Calls for Unity After Imam Attacked

Image

Fan challenges Rochester Honkers to a win

Image

Essential Worker Convoy

Image

Olmsted County Election Prep

Image

Move With The Mayor

Image

Princess Kay of The Milky Way Is Crowned

Image

Rochester Events Cancelled

Community Events