Why Nancy Pelosi makes a lot of sense as speaker

A group of House Democrats are trying to stop Nancy Pelosi from becoming speaker next Congress. It's not cle...

Posted: Nov 21, 2018 12:20 PM
Updated: Nov 21, 2018 12:20 PM

A group of House Democrats are trying to stop Nancy Pelosi from becoming speaker next Congress. It's not clear at this point whether they'll be successful.

They claim that it's time for new leadership, after Democrats won a majority on a message of change. Fair enough. Pelosi has been in Congress since the 1980s. Some members are tired of the same leadership. (Polling indicates that a number of voters feel that way.)

Demographic groups

Elections and campaigns

Females (demographic group)

Government and public administration

Government organizations - US

Liberalism

Nancy Pelosi

Political Figures - US

Political organizations

Politics

Population and demographics

Society

US Congress

US Democratic Party

US House of Representatives

US political parties

Voters and voting

Speakers, though, have almost always had many years of experience. Would-be speakers typically rise through the ranks. Even Paul Ryan, a Wisconsin Republican who was not the first in line to become speaker in 2015, had been a member of the House since 1999.

From my perspective, there are two big reasons why a candidate for speaker wouldn't be a good fit: She or he hurts her or his party electorally or the speaker is not representative of the party they represent. I don't think either of these reasons applies to Pelosi when you look at the numbers.

It is true that the California Democrat is unpopular. Back in August, for example, a Fox News poll put Pelosi's favorable rating at 29% to an unfavorable rating of 54%. That's not very good. Of course, most congressional leaders have lousy favorability ratings. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell had a 22% favorable rating and an unfavorable rating of 52% in the same poll. The Kentucky Republican's net favorable rating (favorable minus unfavorable) was 5 points worse than Pelosi's in that poll.

Interestingly, you don't hear a lot of Republicans clamoring to replace McConnell right now. It could be that Democrats haven't been as effective as Republicans in using the opposing party's leadership in Congress as a political attack. It may also be that Republicans understand that most people don't vote for Congress based on who the leader will be.

Earlier this year, I looked at how well congressional leader popularity predicted House results. It turned out there was little correlation with the approval or favorable rating of these leaders and how people end up voting for the House.

Indeed, there's a history of voters electing and then re-electing majorities to Congress even when they don't like the person who would most likely be House speaker. We saw that in 1994, 1998, 2014 and now 2018. Likewise, there are years when speakers who aren't all that unpopular seeing their parties voted out (see 1994 and 2006).

People instead are far more likely to base their votes for Congress on how they feel about the president. A CNN poll taken earlier this year found that only 34% of voters said Pelosi was an important factor in their midterm votes, while 68% said President Donald Trump was. Not surprisingly, the President's net approval rating in the exit polls (-9 points) matched nearly perfectly with the Republican deficit in the House popular vote (currently 8 points).

Think of it another way. If Pelosi was such an electoral albatross, Democrats wouldn't be heading toward their biggest net gain in the House since Watergate.

The other main argument one could lodge against someone being speaker is she or he is not representative of the caucus she or he is representing.

Ideologically, Pelosi is a good fit for her party. The Democratic Party is moving further to the left. A record percentage of Democrats identify as liberal, according to Gallup. In this year's exit poll, a record percentage of all voters identified as liberal.

Pelosi is very liberal. According to Voteview, which measures ideology through roll call votes, Pelosi was more liberal than more than 80% of Democratic House members this Congress. She was more liberal than 93% of all House members this Congress.

Pelosi's liberalness may be why those who want her dislodged are primarily in the center of the electorate. This includes incoming freshmen like Abigail Spanberger, who hails from a Virginia district Trump won by over 6 points, and Conor Lamb of Pennsylvania, who was the most moderate House member this Congress.

On the other hand, more liberal members of the House are generally supportive of Pelosi. Incoming member Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York has said she is "going to support the most progressive candidate that's leading the party and right now that is Nancy Pelosi, in terms of running."

Perhaps less spoken about is that Pelosi is a woman in a party in which women are playing a bigger and bigger role. It could be argued that a woman should lead a party whose voters are overwhelmingly women. In the exit polls, 58% of those who cast House ballots for the Democratic Party were women.

Democratic voters also made it clear that they wanted women to represent them. Women were nominated at a record pace in Democratic primaries. There are going to be 89 women serving in the Democratic caucus next year, according to the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers University. That's a record, and 28 more than are serving now.

Without Pelosi, it's possible that there wouldn't be a woman in a position of power representing the party. Rep. Marcia Fudge of Ohio, who was toying with a challenge to Pelosi, would have alleviated that problem. Fudge, though, has decided she won't challenge Pelosi.

Fudge would have been an interesting option for another reason: She's African-American. That would have presented Democrats with the opportunity to reflect the diversity of their party in their leadership selection. Nonwhite voters are far more likely to be Democrats than Republicans, though a larger share of Democratic voters are white than nonwhite.

The bottom line, however, is that it still makes a lot of sense for Democrats to elect Pelosi as speaker. Her strengths outweigh her weaknesses, from an electoral and representative angle. That's probably why no one has stepped forth to challenge her yet.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 552117

Reported Deaths: 7073
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin1149761676
Ramsey47562851
Dakota42219422
Anoka38230415
Washington24823273
Stearns20893218
St. Louis16688297
Scott15865117
Wright14700126
Olmsted1270397
Sherburne1052180
Carver974845
Clay780689
Rice7588101
Blue Earth693240
Kandiyohi626079
Crow Wing612186
Chisago546650
Otter Tail541373
Benton527997
Mower450032
Douglas440570
Goodhue440471
Winona437849
Nobles399448
Morrison392559
McLeod391554
Isanti373559
Beltrami371357
Itasca368352
Polk364467
Steele359914
Becker352048
Lyon347348
Carlton328152
Freeborn325529
Pine310321
Nicollet305342
Brown293839
Mille Lacs279550
Le Sueur268822
Todd267730
Cass248726
Meeker234137
Waseca230720
Martin212329
Wabasha19943
Roseau196318
Hubbard171241
Renville171243
Dodge17083
Redwood166035
Houston162414
Cottonwood156221
Fillmore15159
Pennington150619
Chippewa145236
Wadena143521
Faribault143319
Sibley135210
Kanabec129221
Aitkin128436
Watonwan12549
Rock122319
Jackson116810
Yellow Medicine110119
Pipestone109425
Murray10209
Pope10156
Swift99418
Marshall85517
Stevens81310
Lake78219
Clearwater77114
Wilkin76712
Koochiching76512
Lac qui Parle73522
Big Stone5594
Lincoln5572
Grant5478
Norman5229
Mahnomen4978
Unassigned48578
Kittson46422
Red Lake3887
Traverse3595
Lake of the Woods3053
Cook1440

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 357296

Reported Deaths: 5818
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk55892604
Linn20270329
Scott19017234
Black Hawk15532306
Woodbury14878221
Johnson1401781
Dubuque13127202
Dallas1088496
Pottawattamie10713162
Story1029847
Warren554486
Clinton536690
Cerro Gordo521386
Webster507791
Sioux505573
Marshall476974
Muscatine458996
Des Moines440765
Wapello4251120
Buena Vista421640
Jasper407670
Plymouth396979
Lee368155
Marion354475
Jones293055
Henry285937
Bremer279160
Carroll279051
Crawford262240
Boone257933
Benton249955
Washington249350
Dickinson241243
Mahaska224450
Jackson217842
Kossuth212562
Clay210325
Tama206671
Delaware202539
Winneshiek194033
Page190320
Buchanan188531
Cedar183923
Fayette182941
Wright180035
Hardin179542
Hamilton178049
Harrison175673
Clayton166855
Butler162534
Mills158320
Cherokee156938
Floyd155242
Lyon154541
Madison153719
Poweshiek152533
Allamakee149051
Iowa145324
Hancock143334
Winnebago135831
Grundy135032
Cass134354
Calhoun133211
Jefferson130535
Emmet128440
Shelby127537
Sac127019
Appanoose126647
Louisa126549
Mitchell125241
Union124032
Chickasaw122515
Humboldt118226
Guthrie117829
Franklin112521
Palo Alto110622
Howard102822
Montgomery100237
Unassigned10020
Clarke98123
Keokuk94430
Monroe93628
Ida89533
Adair84432
Pocahontas83421
Monona80930
Davis79924
Greene76510
Osceola75116
Lucas74922
Worth7088
Taylor65112
Fremont61210
Decatur5899
Van Buren55518
Ringgold53623
Wayne52123
Audubon4939
Adams3284
Rochester/St. Mary'S
Partly Cloudy
57° wxIcon
Hi: 60° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 57°
Mason City
Clear
60° wxIcon
Hi: 61° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 60°
Albert Lea
Partly Cloudy
57° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 57°
Austin
Partly Cloudy
59° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 59°
Charles City
Partly Cloudy
59° wxIcon
Hi: 60° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 59°
Pleasant conditions for the weekend
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Latest Video

Image

Byron baseball starts season strong

Image

Hayfield BB PKG

Image

Minnesota DNR offering virtual firearm safety classes for youth

Image

Aaron's Saturday Forecast (4/17/21)

Image

North Broadway Avenue project begins Monday

Image

Aaron's Evening Forecast (4/16/21)

Image

Mom hosting Prom

Image

Vaccines for manufacturing

Image

Countdown to the falcon eggs hatching

Image

Share the Love supports Ronald McDonald House

Community Events