Carlos Ghosn's arrest shows that even visionaries need oversight

The downfall of Nissan Chairman Carlos Ghosn is a painful reminder that everyone needs a boss, even the most...

Posted: Nov 20, 2018 5:35 PM
Updated: Nov 20, 2018 5:35 PM

The downfall of Nissan Chairman Carlos Ghosn is a painful reminder that everyone needs a boss, even the most powerful captains of industry.

Ghosn, who was arrested on Monday over what Nissan called "significant acts of misconduct," served as both the CEO and chairman of Nissan until last year. And he holds both those titles at Renault, the French auto giant. Shares of both companies plunged on the loss of their visionary leader.

Business executives

Business figures

Carlos Ghosn

Companies

Jeffrey Immelt

Labor and employment

Nissan Motor Corporation

Workers and professionals

Arrests

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Criminal law

Law and legal system

Law enforcement

When CEOs grab too much power, accountability and responsibility sometimes go out the window.

That lack of oversight can lead to fraud, such as with the demise of Enron under Kenneth Lay or Tyco under Dennis Kozlowski.

Other imperial CEOs, like Dick Fuld of Lehman Brothers, enabled reckless risk-taking that ruined their companies. John Stumpf failed to fix Wells Fargo's toxic sales culture. And Jeff Immelt made a series of bad decisions that have come back to haunt General Electric.

"You need checks and balances," said Ralph Walkling, founder of the Raj & Kamla Gupta Governance Institute at Drexel University.

"The board's primary job is to hire and fire the CEO. And the board is run by the chairman. When those two roles are combined, it can present an awkward situation," said Walkling.

Whistleblower complaint

Over his 40-year career, Ghosn became one of the most influential executives in the auto industry. He was the architect behind the global alliance of Nissan, Renault and Japan's Mitsubishi. The three companies employ nearly half a million people in almost 200 countries.

Nissan said on Monday that following a whistleblower complaint it launched an investigation that found Ghosn and board member Greg Kelly had been underreporting Ghosn's compensation. "Numerous other significant acts of misconduct have been uncovered, such as personal use of company assets," Nissan said.

"Ultimate power can ultimately corrupt," said Bill Klepper, a management professor at Columbia University.

Nissan acknowledged that problem on Monday.

"Some things should be corrected like over-concentration of power and corporate governance," Nissan CEO Hiroto Saikawa said during a press conference.

Boards have long been pressured to break up the CEO and chairman roles. Keeping the roles together is tantamount to asking the president of the United States to also serve as the chief justice of the Supreme Court. The balance of power is slanted.

"If someone doesn't feel accountable, they may engage in inappropriate acts. They feel invulnerable," said Charles Elson, director of the John L. Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware.

'Undetected flaws'

Plenty of corporate leaders have successfully held both titles. These powerful CEOs have been aided by the naming of respected lead independent directors charged with providing oversight.

For instance, Jamie Dimon is widely credited with steering JPMorgan Chase (JPM) through the financial crisis. Dimon, chairman and CEO for a dozen years, has turned JPMorgan into the biggest and perhaps most successful American big bank.

With Jeff Bezos as chairman and CEO, Amazon (AMZN) has become the most dominant company in Corporate America, and Bezos became the world's richest person.

"Some imperial CEOs can lead very successfully," said Walkling.

But he cautioned that the downside is also higher when there is that much power concentrated in one individual.

"The problem is if there are undetected flaws in your leader and you come upon allegations of misconduct, the company takes a hard fall," said Walkling.

Consider the turmoil at Tesla (TSLA). Facing an SEC lawsuit for allegedly "false and misleading" statements, Elon Musk was forced to give up the chairman role.

And a series of scandals at Facebook (FB) has led to calls for chairman and CEO Mark Zuckerberg to relinquish some of his vast power. Zuckerberg has the majority of voting power at Facebook.

Imperial CEOs are less common

Even though Zuckerberg has resisted calls to separate his roles at Facebook, the trend in Corporate America is moving in that direction, albeit slowly.

Fifty-three percent of S&P 500 companies currently have separate CEO and chairs, according to management consulting firm Korn/Ferry. That's up from 42% in 2011 and 26% in 2001.

And when imperial CEOs have stepped down, many companies are naming an independent chair. That's what Wells Fargo (WFC) did when Stumpf left under pressure in 2016. Former Federal Reserve governor Elizabeth Duke became Wells Fargo's chair this year.

Just 7% of S&P 500 companies that named a new CEO in 2017 combined the CEO and chair titles, according to executive search firm Spencer Stuart. That's down from 30% in 2010.

Despite its stumbles under Immelt, GE (GE) still has not done so. Immelt's immediate replacement John Flannery served as both chairman and CEO. Ditto for Larry Culp, who took over on October 1.

"A good CEO shouldn't fear a separate chair," Elson said. "They should welcome it."

-- CNN's Jethro Mullen and Daniel Shane contributed to this report.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 88721

Reported Deaths: 2015
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hennepin25628921
Ramsey10410318
Dakota7048125
Anoka5664132
Stearns371523
Washington352655
Scott238633
Olmsted226327
Nobles192616
Blue Earth15786
Wright15087
Carver13307
St. Louis131733
Rice12978
Mower12744
Clay123240
Sherburne107814
Kandiyohi9182
Winona84318
Lyon6384
Steele5162
Freeborn5113
Benton5003
Watonwan4984
Nicollet49616
Todd4732
Le Sueur4434
McLeod4402
Chisago4331
Waseca4258
Crow Wing41918
Otter Tail3794
Beltrami3714
Goodhue3249
Martin3049
Itasca27113
Polk2704
Isanti2440
Becker2422
Pine2390
Douglas2361
Carlton2351
Cottonwood2160
Pipestone2099
Morrison1951
Dodge1900
Chippewa1891
Unassigned18752
Sibley1763
Meeker1712
Wabasha1700
Brown1682
Murray1522
Yellow Medicine1482
Rock1460
Mille Lacs1413
Faribault1300
Redwood1290
Jackson1281
Renville1256
Cass1233
Swift1111
Roseau1100
Pennington1081
Houston1070
Fillmore1050
Kanabec1038
Koochiching1033
Lincoln1010
Stevens911
Pope860
Hubbard760
Aitkin701
Big Stone660
Wadena620
Grant574
Wilkin553
Lake530
Norman510
Marshall481
Mahnomen451
Lac qui Parle430
Red Lake370
Traverse290
Clearwater250
Lake of the Woods201
Kittson120
Cook60

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 79506

Reported Deaths: 1256
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Polk15227256
Johnson498527
Woodbury494461
Black Hawk433686
Linn3762106
Story327917
Scott276527
Dubuque276040
Dallas267538
Pottawattamie197637
Buena Vista194112
Marshall175934
Sioux13203
Wapello125757
Webster118914
Clinton106218
Muscatine106052
Plymouth103420
Crawford9944
Cerro Gordo99321
Warren9276
Jasper75632
Des Moines7377
Marion7074
Tama68731
Carroll6305
Henry6034
Lee5947
Wright5621
Dickinson4836
Bremer4637
Boone4627
Washington43011
Louisa42515
Mahaska33619
Franklin33517
Delaware3293
Hamilton3143
Floyd2963
Jackson2963
Winneshiek2935
Clay2883
Benton2811
Hardin2761
Winnebago26611
Butler2582
Clarke2553
Emmet25210
Jones2433
Poweshiek2438
Allamakee2425
Shelby2421
Lyon2413
Buchanan2351
Clayton2303
Cedar2191
Guthrie2175
Kossuth2170
Sac2090
Chickasaw2070
Grundy2012
Madison2012
Fayette1871
Cherokee1852
Howard1825
Iowa1821
Mitchell1810
Harrison1772
Hancock1722
Humboldt1713
Calhoun1692
Mills1651
Palo Alto1590
Pocahontas1512
Monroe14610
Page1410
Lucas1386
Jefferson1331
Monona1321
Cass1292
Osceola1250
Appanoose1203
Union1203
Taylor1191
Davis1134
Van Buren1091
Worth1020
Ida960
Keokuk901
Montgomery865
Greene840
Fremont820
Wayne812
Adair641
Audubon591
Decatur580
Ringgold412
Adams280
Unassigned230
Rochester
Clear
52° wxIcon
Hi: 71° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 52°
Mason City
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 50°
Albert Lea
Clear
54° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 54°
Austin
Clear
52° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 52°
Charles City
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 50°
Warmer Weather Ahead
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Latest Video

Image

Saturday Weather

Image

What are the benefits of bringing football back to Minnesota this fall?

Image

Candlelight vigil for Prisoners of War

Image

MC Masters National Championship Regatta

Image

Early voting begins in Minnesota

Image

Dooley's Pub closes due to health hazards

Image

Area athletic directors prep to welcome back sports

Image

Early voting begins in Minnesota

Image

TikTok Ban to Begin This Weekend

Image

Sara's Evening Forecast - Friday

Community Events