STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Warsaw wants her out. But Poland's top judge says she's staying put

Poland's most senior judge has defied controversial government reforms lowering the retirement age, vowing t...

Posted: Sep 28, 2018 4:55 AM
Updated: Sep 28, 2018 4:55 AM

Poland's most senior judge has defied controversial government reforms lowering the retirement age, vowing to remain at her post until 2020 -- unless the constitution is changed or she dies.

Malgorzata Gersdorf, the 65-year-old head of Poland's Supreme Court, told CNN that the government's judicial reforms were "dangerous" to democracy in a country already in "friction" with the rest of Europe.

Continents and regions

Eastern Europe

Europe

European Union

Government organizations - Intl

Poland

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Government organizations - US

Politics

US federal court system

US federal government

US Supreme Court

Donald Trump

Political Figures - US

Law and legal system

Warsaw

Hungary

Gersdorf's comments come as the European Commission on Monday decided to sue Warsaw for violating the independence of its judiciary. It's the latest step in the Commission's complex disciplinary action against Poland for breaching European Union core principles, exposing the deep unease in parts of Europe with the policies pursued by Warsaw's right-wing Law and Justice party (PiS).

As part of government reforms, the retirement age of Supreme Court judges was lowered from 70 to 65 -- a move affecting 27 of the 72 sitting judges. Not that Gersdorf is having any of it.

"I will not resign," she told CNN during an interview in her Warsaw office, where she has returned to work almost every day since the new laws came into effect in April. "But I may not be able to do this honorable job," she added.

"In my mind, I will remain the First President of the Supreme Court until 30th April, 2020. And only changing the constitution can alter that -- or my dying," said the justice who had been serving a six-year term under the constitution.

The judge who defied the law

Under the reforms, judges can also ask the Polish president to prolong their mandate -- something Gersdorf has previously dismissed as equal to "subordination."

But the PiS has said the reforms are needed to rectify an ineffective judicial system influenced by communist-era judges. The Polish government had not replied to a CNN request for comment at time of publishing.

Gersdorf, wearing a necklace bearing the word "Konstytucja" or "Constitution" was quick to dismiss the government's reasoning. "This is fake news spread by government officials, because there are no corrupt individuals in the Supreme Court," she said.

"If there were any, we would have prosecutions. Nor are there any people who would have had a dark page under communism, because they would not have been admitted into the Supreme Court in the 1990s, when the court was reconstituted."

Defying a government deadline to ask for a prolonged mandate, she turned up to work flanked by hundreds of supporters in July. "It was wonderful," she recalled. "I received beautiful flowers and there was a lot of support for my attitude."

Gersdorf has since become something of a celebrity of the resistance movement, but admits Polish society is still "split" on the reforms.

"There are pro-government firebrands who only listen to one side of the story, to their media. And that shows on the internet, in their verdict on my position," she said. "To these people, I am a German, a sell-out, practically all that is worst," Gersdorf said, possibly referring to suggestions that she was unpatriotic and on the side of pro-EU Germany, rather than Poland.

"But there is a section of society which strongly supports me in my struggle for democracy and for judiciary independence, and I can see this each morning in front of the court," she said.

Trump praises Poland

Among those backing the Polish government, is US President Donald Trump. On Tuesday, a day after the Commission referred Warsaw to its highest court, the European Court of Justice, over its judicial reforms, Trump praised Poland in a speech at the United Nations General Assembly in New York.

"In Poland, a great people are standing up for their independence, their security, and their sovereignty," he said. Trump made his remarks a week after saying that the US was considering placing a permanent military base in Poland and the country's president proposed naming it "Fort Trump" in his honor.

Poland's ally Hungary is also facing disciplinary action from the EU for its alleged crackdown on democratic institutions. Both countries are facing punishment under Article 7 -- a disciplinary process that could ultimately lead to their suspension of voting rights from the bloc.

Europe's ideological divide

It's the first time the bloc has triggered Article 7, exposing a deepening ideological divide between a growing alliance of populist governments, and Brussels.

Gersdorf said there were some "frictions" between Poland and Hungary, and other European states, although she didn't go as far as to see it as a "drifting apart."

Of greater concern to her was the blurring of lines between the government and the judicial system in Poland.

"This is very dangerous, not only for society here and now, but also for the very ruling party, should it lose power," said Gersdorf.

"Because those undemocratic instruments they have created may be turned against them. And that is what really worries me -- that it may be an instrument which will take root in Poland."

'I haven't always been so stern'

Gersdorf was "born into a family of jurists" and says she immensely enjoyed their legal conversations at home, deciding from an early age that she wanted to be a lawyer. After a lifetime in law, including as a professor at the University of Warsaw, Gersdorf became the First President of the Supreme Court in 2014.

Four years later, she is fighting to stay in the job she describes as the "crowning" moment in her career. How successful she will be, has yet to be seen.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 86722

Reported Deaths: 1994
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hennepin25264915
Ramsey10267314
Dakota6942124
Anoka5531131
Stearns362923
Washington345955
Scott232532
Olmsted223726
Nobles191416
Blue Earth15406
Wright14777
Carver13037
Rice12798
Mower12534
St. Louis123329
Clay119940
Sherburne105013
Kandiyohi9082
Winona72718
Lyon6244
Steele5062
Freeborn4903
Nicollet48716
Watonwan4844
Benton4793
Todd4722
Le Sueur4403
McLeod4332
Chisago4151
Waseca4118
Crow Wing40218
Otter Tail3674
Beltrami3624
Goodhue3179
Martin2809
Polk2574
Itasca25513
Becker2352
Carlton2261
Isanti2210
Douglas2191
Cottonwood2130
Pipestone2059
Pine1980
Morrison1841
Chippewa1821
Dodge1820
Sibley1663
Wabasha1640
Brown1582
Unassigned15752
Meeker1552
Murray1492
Yellow Medicine1421
Rock1390
Mille Lacs1333
Faribault1290
Cass1203
Jackson1201
Renville1176
Pennington1071
Houston1050
Roseau1050
Swift991
Fillmore980
Koochiching983
Kanabec958
Lincoln930
Redwood910
Stevens911
Pope810
Aitkin691
Hubbard650
Big Stone640
Wadena610
Grant574
Wilkin553
Norman510
Lake480
Marshall481
Mahnomen441
Red Lake370
Lac qui Parle360
Traverse290
Clearwater240
Lake of the Woods201
Kittson130
Cook60

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 76924

Reported Deaths: 1241
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Polk14988255
Johnson490727
Woodbury475459
Black Hawk425184
Linn3640102
Story321417
Dallas263238
Scott261427
Dubuque251840
Buena Vista191812
Pottawattamie189437
Marshall175234
Sioux12243
Wapello122057
Webster117914
Muscatine105152
Clinton102418
Cerro Gordo97721
Plymouth97520
Crawford9444
Warren9186
Jasper72032
Des Moines7137
Marion6874
Tama67830
Carroll6085
Lee5727
Wright5491
Henry5104
Dickinson4666
Bremer4497
Boone4346
Washington41411
Louisa41314
Franklin33017
Hamilton3123
Mahaska30919
Delaware3053
Jackson2803
Floyd2793
Winneshiek2745
Clay2663
Hardin2661
Benton2611
Clarke2533
Butler2512
Winnebago24711
Emmet24210
Shelby2381
Allamakee2355
Jones2313
Poweshiek2308
Clayton2243
Lyon2233
Buchanan2181
Cedar2101
Guthrie2095
Chickasaw1970
Kossuth1950
Grundy1932
Madison1922
Howard1764
Sac1760
Fayette1751
Iowa1741
Cherokee1732
Mitchell1720
Hancock1702
Humboldt1682
Harrison1642
Calhoun1612
Mills1541
Pocahontas1492
Palo Alto1480
Monroe1409
Page1400
Jefferson1291
Lucas1296
Cass1262
Monona1251
Taylor1171
Appanoose1163
Osceola1130
Union1123
Davis1104
Van Buren1081
Worth990
Keokuk841
Montgomery845
Greene790
Ida770
Wayne762
Fremont730
Adair591
Decatur580
Audubon501
Ringgold402
Adams270
Unassigned160
Rochester
Few Clouds
54° wxIcon
Hi: 60° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 54°
Mason City
Clear
56° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 56°
Albert Lea
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 57°
Austin
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 57°
Charles City
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 45°
Feels Like: 57°
Cooler to wrap up the work week
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events