Judge: ICE shouldn't 'remove' people applying for green cards just because they have deportation orders

A federal judge in Boston said Thursday that Immigration and Customs Enforcement shouldn't remove people who...

Posted: Aug 24, 2018 11:23 AM
Updated: Aug 24, 2018 11:23 AM

A federal judge in Boston said Thursday that Immigration and Customs Enforcement shouldn't remove people who are in the process of applying for green cards just because they have final orders of removal.

US District Judge Mark Wolf issued the ruling during a hearing in the case of New England couples -- US citizens who are married to undocumented immigrants -- who say they're being caught in a "trap" by the government to arrest immigrants. The couples argue that the "provisional waiver process," which allows undocumented immigrants to try to obtain citizenship, is being used incorrectly.

Arrests

Boston

Citizenship and naturalization

Continents and regions

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Criminal law

Decisions and rulings

Deportation

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Government organizations - US

Immigration

Immigration, citizenship and displacement

International relations and national security

Law and legal system

Law enforcement

Massachusetts

North America

Northeastern United States

The Americas

Trial and procedure

United States

US Department of Homeland Security

US federal departments and agencies

US federal government

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement

Undocumented immigrants

Wolf also denied the government's motion to dismiss the case.

"ICE may only remove them from the US after considering the fact that they were pursuing provisional waivers," Wolf said in court Thursday. "I am not precluding ICE from taking action."

Wolf's statement was not a preliminary injunction, which would have been a court order for ICE to stop deporting undocumented immigrants who were going through the waiver process.

It is unclear if the government would face a penalty if it doesn't abide by the ruling, and if this would apply outside the New England area.

Five New England couples are suing Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen, ICE officials, President Donald Trump and Boston-area law enforcement officials after they said multiple spouses with final orders of removal were detained by ICE after sitting down for marriage interviews with their US-citizen spouses at a Boston-area US Citizenship and Immigration Services office. Such interviews are part of the application process to prove their marriages to US citizens are legitimate, enabling them to move toward legal status.

Emails entered as evidence in the case show what appear to be efforts between Citizenship and Immigration Services employees and ICE employees to coordinate the interview appointments and arrests of people appearing for interviews with final orders of deportation. USCIS said that, in general, when its officers encounter someone with outstanding warrants or removal orders, they will notify the appropriate law enforcement agency. DHS did not comment further.

American Civil Liberties Union attorney Matt Segal, who along with attorneys from the firm WilmerHale is representing the five couples named in this suit, said his interpretation of Thursday's ruling is that while it wasn't styled as a court order, "it is a ruling on the law, and our expectation -- and presumably the court's -- is that the government is going to comply with the law as it's now been interpreted by the court."

"So as of the ruling today the law from the court's perspective is that people cannot be targeted for arrest and removal unless there is consideration given to the fact that they're pursuing this provisional waiver process," Segal said Thursday.

CNN asked the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE, if it plans on complying with the ruling and a spokeswoman replied: "As a matter of policy, we don't comment on pending litigation."

Court filings from the ACLU show that about 13 people have been arrested at marriage interviews in the Boston area since January. The ACLU says it is asking other New England residents to contact them if they are not citizens and believe they are being targeted for ICE arrest or removal, despite being in the process of applying to become lawful permanent residents.

The situations the couples face came to light after a Rhode Island woman, Lilian Calderon, 30, was taken into ICE custody in January when she and her husband went to a nearby USCIS office for a marriage interview so she could begin trying to become a lawful permanent resident.

Calderon is a Guatemalan immigrant who was brought to the US when she was 3 years old. She is married to a US citizen, Luis Gordillo, and the couple has two children. She alleges in the case that after her interview was complete, she was "unexpectedly detained by ICE."

Calderon had been subject to a final order of removal since the age of 15, after her father's asylum application was denied. Her Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals application was also denied in 2017 because, according to the complaint, "she had not provided sufficient evidence of her continuous presence in the United States."

Calderon was held in an ICE detention facility in Boston from January until Feb. 13, after Wolf issued an order prohibiting ICE from deporting her while her lawsuit is pending.

ICE officials testified that they believe the arrest in Calderon's case was justified, per Trump's January 2017 executive order calling for "the faithful execution of immigration laws of the United States ... against all removable aliens."

After Wolf's ruling Thursday, Calderon said, through a spokeswoman, that she and her husband were "delighted" the judge has allowed the case to proceed.

"Luis and I were trying to do what the government asked of us so that our family could continue to be together," Calderon said in the statement to CNN. "This gives us hope that no other family will have to endure what we have."

Both parties are expected to file written status reports on the case to Wolf by Sept. 12.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 98447

Reported Deaths: 2072
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hennepin27557932
Ramsey11167323
Dakota7692126
Anoka6281137
Stearns409424
Washington391855
Scott264833
Olmsted253528
Nobles197916
Blue Earth17366
St. Louis172542
Wright17017
Carver14467
Clay142441
Rice13478
Mower13446
Sherburne117714
Kandiyohi10563
Winona92018
Lyon7334
Waseca7228
Benton5633
Steele5552
Crow Wing55418
Nicollet54717
Freeborn5464
Watonwan5354
Chisago5171
Todd5072
McLeod5022
Le Sueur4764
Otter Tail4694
Beltrami4605
Martin44611
Goodhue3899
Pine3550
Douglas3522
Itasca35215
Polk3274
Isanti3191
Becker2842
Carlton2791
Morrison2702
Dodge2610
Pipestone23810
Chippewa2321
Cottonwood2290
Meeker2132
Wabasha2060
Sibley2023
Yellow Medicine1982
Brown1962
Cass1864
Rock1810
Redwood1783
Murray1742
Mille Lacs1693
Renville1618
Jackson1531
Unassigned15352
Faribault1470
Swift1441
Fillmore1330
Houston1300
Kanabec1288
Roseau1260
Koochiching1233
Hubbard1221
Pennington1201
Lincoln1180
Stevens1071
Pope1000
Aitkin841
Big Stone830
Wadena730
Wilkin713
Lac qui Parle681
Grant634
Lake600
Norman560
Marshall531
Mahnomen491
Red Lake451
Traverse340
Clearwater310
Lake of the Woods241
Kittson120
Cook70

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 87828

Reported Deaths: 1332
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Polk16113264
Woodbury559768
Johnson517927
Black Hawk454192
Linn4163114
Story348517
Dubuque340242
Scott309528
Dallas282938
Pottawattamie220139
Buena Vista200312
Marshall179434
Sioux17073
Wapello134157
Webster131714
Plymouth118221
Clinton113921
Muscatine112855
Crawford11086
Cerro Gordo106421
Warren9696
Jasper87034
Des Moines8068
Henry7734
Marion7728
Tama75332
Carroll6955
Lee6527
Wright5971
Dickinson5426
Boone5268
Bremer5067
Washington48511
Delaware4413
Louisa43415
Mahaska42720
Lyon3754
Jackson3583
Floyd3573
Franklin35218
Clay3434
Winneshiek3408
Benton3381
Hamilton3343
Winnebago32313
Hardin3111
Poweshiek3118
Buchanan2921
Jones2893
Kossuth2860
Butler2792
Emmet27510
Chickasaw2701
Shelby2701
Clarke2693
Clayton2683
Sac2670
Allamakee2656
Guthrie2649
Harrison2593
Cherokee2572
Cedar2531
Fayette2382
Madison2342
Grundy2294
Iowa2221
Palo Alto2080
Hancock1992
Mitchell1970
Humboldt1943
Howard1927
Mills1911
Page1910
Calhoun1883
Osceola1770
Cass1762
Pocahontas1662
Monona1621
Monroe16211
Lucas1566
Appanoose1443
Union1423
Jefferson1401
Taylor1341
Davis1284
Ida1281
Fremont1220
Keokuk1191
Van Buren1181
Worth1090
Greene1050
Montgomery995
Audubon891
Wayne882
Adair731
Decatur670
Ringgold532
Adams330
Unassigned140
Rochester
Overcast
60° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 60°
Mason City
Broken Clouds
63° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 63°
Albert Lea
Broken Clouds
63° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 63°
Austin
Overcast
61° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 61°
Charles City
Broken Clouds
61° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 61°
Winds pick up for Wednesday
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events