Could Elon Musk lose control of Tesla?

Elon Musk wants to take Tesla private and remain in control of the company. He may not be able to do both....

Posted: Aug 17, 2018 8:29 AM
Updated: Aug 17, 2018 8:29 AM

Elon Musk wants to take Tesla private and remain in control of the company. He may not be able to do both.

The plans to take Tesla private are not clear, but Musk suggested in a blog post this week he's going to need a lot of help to buy out shareholders.

If his plan succeeds, the new stakeholders will probably have a much louder voice inside Tesla than the analysts and short-sellers he despises today. They could conceivably demand changes or even his ouster.

Musk said he wants Tesla's stock to be taken private at a premium value of $420 a share, but he also expects about two-thirds of shares now held in the publicly traded Tesla to maintain their current ownership.

That suggests at least 33% of the shares would need to be repurchased before the company could be taken private. That block of stock alone is more than Musk owns or could buy by exercising his options (his stock and options are equal to about 22% of Tesla's oustanding shares). And he doesn't have a lot of free cash to make significant additional purchases, as most of his non-Tesla net worth is tied up in his other company, privately held SpaceX, according to Gene Munster, managing partner at Loup Ventures and a top tech analyst.

A Saudi-owned Tesla?

Musk also disclosed that the Saudis already own nearly 5% of Tesla shares. So Musk could depend on them to purchase only an additional 16%-or-so of Tesla shares or the Saudis would own more of Tesla than he does.

So Tesla and Musk would have to find other investors to put up the roughly $10 billion needed to take Tesla private. But that could force Musk to give a greater voice in Tesla decisions to outsiders, said Todd Boudreau, chair of private equity group at Foley & Lardner. He said the demand of private equity investors for a say in the company will increase depending upon the size of the investment they put up.

"To bring in some investors, they're going to want some control," said Boudreau. The private investors could even cause him more problems than the short sellers and analysts he disdains, Boudreau said. Exerting influence on a publicly traded company can be an expensive and difficult process involving proxy fights and board elections. But when there is a limited group of private investors who together own a controlling stake in a company, they can act much more quickly.

"If they're all on board with what you're doing, it's ideal. But the dynamic can change very quickly. In the most extreme case, he could be out tomorrow," he said.

Who will own the most shares?

Musk will probably work to make sure no one else holds more than 20% of the company, said Munster.

"We think that (someone owning more than Musk) would be a deal breaker," he said.

"Everyone is going to have to be a passive investor. Elon Musk won't let anyone be active," Munster said. "I think the point of going private is he's tired of people telling him how to run his business."

But the difficulty in finding that much passive money to put into the deal is the reason he thinks there is a one-in-three chance that the deal to take it private never gets done.

Tesla did not respond to a request for additional comment for this story.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 446380

Reported Deaths: 5995
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin927471474
Ramsey39820736
Dakota32876338
Anoka30877363
Washington20066227
Stearns17813187
St. Louis13609241
Scott1191796
Wright11570104
Olmsted1041375
Sherburne818965
Carver692436
Clay650280
Rice604168
Kandiyohi553471
Blue Earth538933
Crow Wing481374
Otter Tail454466
Chisago450832
Benton418685
Winona387246
Douglas373466
Nobles368746
Mower363329
Goodhue345358
Polk327956
McLeod324245
Morrison311144
Beltrami309447
Lyon300636
Becker284139
Itasca284043
Isanti281641
Carlton278543
Steele27229
Pine266013
Freeborn243420
Todd231630
Nicollet223836
Brown214534
Mille Lacs213646
Le Sueur208815
Cass207323
Meeker199233
Waseca188916
Wabasha16953
Martin169326
Roseau165416
Hubbard149238
Redwood139527
Renville137139
Houston135613
Dodge13384
Chippewa130932
Cottonwood126818
Fillmore12245
Wadena119616
Rock109712
Sibley10837
Aitkin107633
Watonwan10638
Faribault104616
Pennington98815
Kanabec97418
Pipestone93923
Yellow Medicine93514
Murray8785
Jackson85210
Swift83118
Pope7375
Marshall70315
Stevens6978
Clearwater68514
Lac qui Parle65716
Lake63215
Wilkin6229
Koochiching59310
Lincoln4821
Big Stone4553
Unassigned43668
Grant4298
Norman4238
Mahnomen4107
Kittson37219
Red Lake3164
Traverse2503
Lake of the Woods1901
Cook1140

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 303464

Reported Deaths: 4269
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk45396448
Linn17695274
Scott15387163
Black Hawk13659236
Woodbury12953175
Johnson1204749
Dubuque11312150
Pottawattamie8942112
Dallas882171
Story863834
Webster467571
Cerro Gordo463568
Sioux453756
Clinton448861
Warren438838
Marshall425761
Buena Vista391929
Muscatine386777
Des Moines380941
Plymouth348968
Wapello341698
Jasper320458
Lee314430
Marion302152
Jones270449
Henry263430
Carroll253434
Bremer242248
Crawford228522
Boone216417
Washington214531
Benton208844
Jackson191131
Mahaska190736
Tama185857
Dickinson184226
Delaware172336
Kossuth171343
Clay166019
Wright163024
Fayette160022
Buchanan158323
Hamilton157929
Winneshiek155119
Harrison154762
Hardin154229
Cedar151819
Clayton150748
Butler146824
Page143715
Cherokee138227
Floyd138036
Mills136016
Lyon133832
Poweshiek132424
Hancock129024
Allamakee126927
Iowa123922
Calhoun12209
Grundy120226
Jefferson119524
Madison11899
Winnebago118529
Mitchell115734
Louisa114330
Cass112641
Chickasaw110612
Sac110615
Emmet110331
Appanoose109838
Union108122
Humboldt104219
Guthrie102424
Franklin101618
Shelby101426
Unassigned9160
Palo Alto9019
Keokuk84325
Montgomery84022
Howard82819
Monroe80818
Clarke7847
Pocahontas77211
Ida74030
Davis68921
Greene6887
Adair68620
Lucas6488
Osceola6349
Monona63316
Worth5993
Taylor5919
Fremont5046
Van Buren49412
Decatur4804
Ringgold4269
Wayne41421
Audubon4118
Adams2953
Rochester/St. Mary'S
Cloudy
23° wxIcon
Hi: 25° Lo: 20°
Feels Like: 15°
Mason City
Cloudy
22° wxIcon
Hi: 25° Lo: 17°
Feels Like: 13°
Albert Lea
Cloudy
21° wxIcon
Hi: 22° Lo: 18°
Feels Like: 21°
Austin
Cloudy
23° wxIcon
Hi: 23° Lo: 18°
Feels Like: 17°
Charles City
Cloudy
21° wxIcon
Hi: 24° Lo: 15°
Feels Like: 21°
A big temperature swing is on the way
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events