Judge ahead of family reunifications deadline: Progress 'remarkable' but still 'deeply troubling'

A federal judge on Tuesday called progress ahead of his deadline for reunifying families separated at the border "rem...

Posted: Jul 25, 2018 10:31 AM
Updated: Jul 25, 2018 10:31 AM

A federal judge on Tuesday called progress ahead of his deadline for reunifying families separated at the border "remarkable," but said he also still finds "deeply troubling" the effects of the government's original policy that led to most of the separations.

District Judge Dana Sabraw made the comments during a status hearing Tuesday in an ongoing lawsuit over the separations, two days before his deadline for the government to reunite those families.

"This is a remarkable achievement," Sabraw said, adding the government should be "commended."

During the hearing, the government said 1,012 families have already been reunited -- over 100 more than had been reunited by Monday evening's status update.

Sabraw said he expects that his Thursday deadline will essentially be met and he expected to be satisfied by the next hearing Friday.

"For class members who are eligible, it appears that when we meet on this issue again on Friday that reunification will have been completed on time, which has to be highlighted and the government has to be commended for its efforts in that regard," Sabraw said.

But there are still 914 parents who are either ineligible or not determined, and Sabraw noted that that group likely cannot be reunited on time, even with the best effort by the government.

Going forward, he said the American Civil Liberties Union, which filed the lawsuit, needs "more information." He said the process needs to be even more "transparent."

"Some of this information is unpleasant," Sabraw said. "It's the reality of the case, it's the reality of a policy that was in place that resulted in large numbers of families being separated without forethought as to reunification and keeping track of people. And that's the fallout we're seeing. There may be 463, there may be more, it's not certain, but it appears there's a large number of parents who are unaccounted for or who may have been removed without their child."

He continued: "That's a deeply troubling reality of the case and the plaintiffs are entitled to that information. So there has to be an accounting."

Sabraw ordered the government to begin providing its lists of remaining parents to the ACLU on Wednesday, even if they are incomplete.

A little more than 200 parents have criminal records or declined to be reunified, more than 200 have been released, more than 460 are believed to not be in the country and another roughly 260 require further investigation, according to the government.

As for the 463 who are indicated as out of the country, the government could not say if they had all been deported without their children, as is likely. Justice Department attorney Sarah Fabian said the government was having to review each case file to figure out where that parent was.

"The records recorded reflect 463 with a code that suggests that they may have departed the United States. What I understand we are doing is taking a closer look at those," Fabian said. "So it may be a removal or it may be a voluntary departure that is unrelated to a separation or it may be a prior code."

'Things are a mess'

As the hearing turned to the ACLU's request to require seven days before reunified parents are deported to allow time to weigh the decision as a family, the organization raised the frantic conditions on the ground, some of which CNN has reported.

"Talking to people on the ground now, and we have an enormous number of affidavits ... things are really a mess on the ground," ACLU attorney Lee Gelernt said. "I think you're going to be shocked when you see these affidavits."

Gelernt said that despite orders for communication between parents and children to occur, there was a "vast difference" between what had been ordered and what happened. Sometimes only one phone call between parent and child occurred. He referenced the form parents sign to authorize their deportation without their child, which is supposed to be given to them only if they have been ordered deported.

"Parents have no idea what's happening. They've signed these forms, many of them, to show you how much the confusion there is, many of them actually signed the forms giving away their child even though they didn't have a final order," Gelernt said. "There are group presentations ... the parents were put in groups of 50 and said, 'Here are your basic rights. You have three minutes to sign these forms.' "

The government grew openly frustrated with the suggestion that the ACLU would be filing the affidavits.

"I'm disappointed to hear that Mr. Gelernt is suddenly planning to file a raft ... of declarations. The government was caught off guard and quite by surprise when this motion was filed" in the first place, said Justice Department attorney Scott Stewart. "Now I get a signal that despite our significant jurisdictional objections, our days and nights trying to negotiate ... that we're about to be hit by a raft of affidavits."

He also disputed the accusations.

"We have many reasons to be very proud of this effort," he said. "So we strongly contest that characterization and look forward to the opportunity to present further views on that."

The judge asked for the ACLU to file its latest position by Wednesday.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 60898

Reported Deaths: 1698
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Hennepin19271835
Ramsey7572265
Dakota4414106
Anoka3683114
Stearns289320
Washington212845
Nobles17646
Olmsted173223
Scott155919
Mower11012
Rice10328
Blue Earth9185
Wright8845
Carver8613
Clay78440
Sherburne7238
Kandiyohi6961
St. Louis55319
Todd4262
Lyon4253
Freeborn3591
Steele3482
Nicollet33713
Benton3203
Watonwan3080
Winona26116
Beltrami2400
Crow Wing23514
Le Sueur2201
Martin2075
Chisago2011
Goodhue1969
Otter Tail1943
McLeod1810
Cottonwood1780
Becker1571
Pipestone1579
Polk1534
Waseca1480
Itasca14712
Douglas1441
Carlton1370
Unassigned13441
Pine1290
Dodge1270
Isanti1250
Murray1221
Chippewa1041
Morrison921
Wabasha920
Brown892
Faribault870
Jackson860
Meeker852
Rock850
Sibley832
Koochiching773
Pennington751
Cass722
Mille Lacs713
Renville645
Fillmore630
Lincoln580
Grant553
Swift531
Roseau520
Yellow Medicine520
Pope480
Houston420
Aitkin401
Norman400
Kanabec361
Redwood360
Wilkin343
Hubbard330
Marshall290
Mahnomen271
Wadena270
Red Lake240
Big Stone220
Lake210
Stevens180
Clearwater140
Traverse110
Lac qui Parle70
Cook50
Kittson30
Lake of the Woods20

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 48781

Reported Deaths: 929
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Polk10309207
Woodbury371952
Black Hawk312766
Linn237588
Johnson209619
Dallas188535
Buena Vista179412
Scott171814
Dubuque167631
Marshall144426
Pottawattamie132526
Story116614
Wapello90033
Muscatine84748
Webster8017
Crawford7283
Sioux6343
Cerro Gordo62517
Warren5641
Tama55129
Jasper47826
Wright4721
Plymouth4629
Clinton3973
Dickinson3814
Louisa37814
Washington29810
Boone2583
Hamilton2461
Franklin24110
Bremer2267
Clarke2013
Carroll1921
Emmet1924
Clay1901
Shelby1841
Hardin1810
Des Moines1792
Marion1730
Poweshiek1598
Benton1561
Jackson1561
Allamakee1554
Floyd1552
Mahaska13917
Cedar1331
Guthrie1325
Jones1302
Buchanan1271
Henry1254
Hancock1222
Butler1212
Madison1212
Pocahontas1152
Lee1143
Lyon1132
Delaware1121
Humboldt1111
Cherokee1081
Harrison1071
Clayton1043
Taylor980
Iowa971
Winneshiek971
Page940
Kossuth910
Monona910
Mills890
Sac850
Jefferson840
Palo Alto840
Winnebago840
Calhoun832
Osceola830
Fayette820
Grundy791
Mitchell780
Union771
Cass741
Monroe737
Lucas684
Worth660
Montgomery594
Davis572
Chickasaw540
Appanoose493
Howard490
Fremont420
Greene410
Van Buren371
Keokuk351
Adair300
Ida290
Audubon281
Decatur230
Ringgold221
Wayne191
Adams160
Unassigned60
Rochester
Few Clouds
65° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 65°
Mason City
Clear
62° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 62°
Albert Lea
Clear
64° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 64°
Austin
Clear
64° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 52°
Feels Like: 64°
Charles City
Clear
64° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 53°
Feels Like: 64°
Storm chances End, Cooler & Less Humid Ahead
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Latest Video

Image

Preparing for Minnesota's Primary

Image

American Legion starting '100 Miles of Hope' for veterans and children

Image

Diversity Council hosts 'Allies and Advocates'

Image

More construction in downtown Rochester starts

Image

NIACC baseball pushing athletes to the next level

Image

Sunday weather

Image

Weather

Image

Rochester Area Restore celebrates 6 years

Image

Saturday Weather

Image

Grief mask making workshop

Community Events