Sotomayor dissent tackles impact of Ohio ruling on minority voters

All four liberals on the Supreme Court dissented in Monday's 5-4 case ...

Posted: Jun 12, 2018 7:26 AM
Updated: Jun 12, 2018 7:26 AM

All four liberals on the Supreme Court dissented in Monday's 5-4 case upholding Ohio's method of removing voters from its rolls.

Justice Stephen Breyer led the charge, interpreting the National Voter Registration Act, also known as the motor voter law, as barring Ohio's process. Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor joined the dissent in full.

But then, on her own, Sotomayor went further and focused on something else: the impact the ruling will have on minority voters.

"Our democracy rests on the ability of all individuals, regardless of race, income or status, to exercise their right to vote," she wrote in a separate five-page dissent.

Her opinion earned a rebuke from conservative Justice Samuel Alito, who wrote the majority opinion. It also prompted some to question if laws like Ohio's could be challenged down the road as discriminatory. But more than anything else, it reflected a common theme that Sotomayor weaves into her opinions and speaking engagements: a law's effect on society.

Just last week, Sotomayor appeared before the liberal American Constitution Society and spoke about her style.

She was asked if she felt the "weight of being the only woman of color on the court."

"Yes," she responded. "To the extent that I speak frankly in my decisions, and directly, it's because I want people to understand what I am saying, not in legal terms, but in legal terms that touch the heart. I want people to understand the consequences of law and how it affects them."

Back in 2014, professor David Fontana, writing for the Yale Law Journal, dubbed Sotomayor the "people's justice" in part because of what he called her "extrajudicial communications" that he said differed from those of other recent liberal justices.

To be sure on Monday, she joined Breyer's dense and technical opinion that explored where he felt the majority went wrong in its statutory interpretation. Breyer actually included the full text of the law to make his point.

But writing alone, Sotomayor focused on the effect of Ohio's system.

She started with the fact that the 1993 law was enacted "against the backdrop of substantial efforts by States to disenfranchise low-income and minority voters, including programs that purged eligible voters from registration lists because they failed to vote in prior elections."

Sotomayor accused the majority of "ignoring this history" and "distorting" the statute.

And while Ohio has always argued that its goal was to make a "reasonable effort" to remove ineligible voters, she said that such removal programs must be developed in a manner "that prevents poor and illiterate voters from being caught in a purge system which will require them to needlessly re-register and prevents abuse which has a disparate impact on minority communities. "

And she pointed to one of the amicus briefs in the case that revealed that in one county, "African-American-majority neighborhoods in downtown Cincinnati had 10% of their voters removed due to inactivity since 2012" as compared to "only 4% of voters in a suburban, majority-white neighborhood."

"We have seen state officials across the country using purge programs as a vehicle to remove legitimately registered voters from the rolls," Kristen Clarke, the President of the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, said after the opinion was released.

But Alito, who wrote the majority opinion and was joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Anthony Kennedy, Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch, singled out Sotomayor.

"Justice Sotomayor's dissent says nothing about what is relevant in this case," he said. Instead of focusing on the reach of the federal law, Sotomayor "accuses us of ignoring the history of voter suppression."

He called such charges "misconceived" and said that she had not pointed to "any evidence in the record that Ohio instituted or has carried out its program with discriminatory intent."

And Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted praised Alito's opinion and disregarded Sotomayor's dissent.

He called the ruling a "validation of Ohio's efforts" to clean up voter rolls. And he said the majority has now given its "blessing" for other states to follow suit.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 485230

Reported Deaths: 6554
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin1006801585
Ramsey43047801
Dakota36254390
Anoka33274384
Washington22065255
Stearns18723201
St. Louis14794262
Scott13273107
Wright12517115
Olmsted1177988
Sherburne871572
Carver771040
Clay690387
Rice670091
Blue Earth593835
Kandiyohi579474
Crow Wing519681
Chisago498445
Otter Tail481870
Benton446190
Winona418049
Mower404131
Douglas392568
Nobles386847
Goodhue385568
Polk342762
McLeod339349
Beltrami337351
Morrison324247
Lyon313044
Itasca312746
Becker310941
Isanti305754
Carlton300149
Steele299711
Pine282016
Freeborn280523
Nicollet258141
Todd247830
Brown244637
Le Sueur235020
Mille Lacs227247
Cass219924
Waseca208917
Meeker207434
Martin189328
Wabasha18623
Roseau180217
Hubbard160640
Houston157314
Dodge15214
Renville149540
Redwood147027
Fillmore13728
Chippewa136335
Cottonwood134820
Pennington134116
Wadena130920
Faribault122917
Aitkin118933
Sibley117310
Watonwan11728
Rock115714
Kanabec107419
Pipestone101424
Yellow Medicine97617
Murray9438
Jackson93510
Swift87918
Pope8025
Marshall77815
Stevens7418
Lake73718
Clearwater71914
Lac qui Parle68316
Wilkin67110
Koochiching61811
Big Stone5163
Lincoln5062
Grant4918
Unassigned47968
Norman4768
Mahnomen4417
Kittson40821
Red Lake3625
Traverse3055
Lake of the Woods2191
Cook1180

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 362189

Reported Deaths: 5414
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk58146549
Linn20653312
Scott18288207
Black Hawk16249291
Woodbury14961211
Johnson1383473
Dubuque13537194
Dallas1135890
Pottawattamie10765143
Story1021645
Warren555274
Clinton543284
Cerro Gordo533681
Webster518787
Marshall496272
Sioux494369
Buena Vista473236
Des Moines457661
Muscatine451191
Wapello4330108
Jasper416966
Plymouth394577
Lee375352
Marion359069
Jones294154
Henry292737
Carroll285548
Bremer280154
Crawford274735
Boone259630
Washington254147
Benton252854
Mahaska224346
Jackson221438
Dickinson217439
Tama213465
Kossuth208154
Clay193525
Hamilton192042
Delaware188839
Winneshiek188427
Buchanan185129
Fayette185035
Page183219
Hardin181039
Wright179731
Harrison179669
Cedar177923
Clayton168053
Butler166331
Mills163120
Floyd162740
Madison154518
Cherokee153935
Poweshiek153730
Hancock146829
Lyon145841
Allamakee145646
Iowa144423
Appanoose139147
Grundy139030
Jefferson138232
Winnebago138230
Cass134151
Calhoun133711
Mitchell130840
Louisa128241
Union126331
Chickasaw125213
Sac124218
Emmet121240
Shelby121033
Franklin118419
Humboldt117425
Guthrie116528
Palo Alto104921
Montgomery103936
Howard103121
Clarke100520
Unassigned9890
Keokuk98129
Monroe93128
Adair91928
Ida91032
Pocahontas85519
Davis82623
Monona81627
Greene77310
Lucas73821
Osceola70514
Worth6987
Taylor66412
Fremont5919
Decatur5789
Van Buren55918
Ringgold52020
Wayne48821
Audubon4869
Adams3264
Rochester/St. Mary'S
Clear
24° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 14°
Feels Like: 12°
Mason City
Clear
24° wxIcon
Hi: 44° Lo: 17°
Feels Like: 11°
Albert Lea
Partly Cloudy
27° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 14°
Feels Like: 15°
Austin
Partly Cloudy
23° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 13°
Feels Like: 9°
Charles City
Partly Cloudy
23° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 15°
Feels Like: 9°
Mild conditions expected this week
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events