SEVERE WX : Special Weather Statement View Alerts

Judge in Brock Turner case faces recall

California judge Aaron Persky faces recall for his controversial ruling in the Stanford sexual assault case. CNN's Dan Simon has the story.

Posted: Jun 4, 2018 1:04 PM
Updated: Jun 4, 2018 1:04 PM

The yard signs are easy to spot. On the left, the head shot of a smiling middle-aged man. On the right, an ominous looking jailhouse mug shot. Judge Aaron Persky and Brock Turner, side by side with these words: Vote Yes on the recall.

"I felt like that was just not a right response for it. This was such an egregious crime," said Matthew Kells, a 41-year-old San Jose resident reflecting on Perksy's six-month jail sentence for Turner, the former Stanford University swimmer convicted of sexually penetrating an unconscious woman. It happened behind a dumpster outside a Stanford fraternity party on January 18, 2015. The victim became known as Emily Doe and has desired to keep her identity private.

"This was as bad as it gets. Having this guy in charge of these decisions just seems ludicrous," said Kells, who has placed a yard sign in front of his home.

It's a sentiment that has Persky on the verge of becoming the first California judge recalled in 86 years.

Behind by double digits in recent polls and recognizing the swell of opposition, Persky, soft-spoken by nature, is trying to make his voice heard in the final days before voters decide his fate on June 5.

"Do you really want a system where a judge can lose his or her job because of one lawful, yet unpopular ruling?" Persky said in an interview.

The public becomes the judge

Self-described as the most hated man on the internet, Perksy, 56, argues that his recall would have a chilling effect on the independence of judges everywhere.

"We must close the door on public opinion. We must do that to preserve the integrity of our criminal justice system, " he said.

Persky's troubles began just days after his decision in June 2016. Prosecutors asked for a six-year prison sentence, but Persky agreed with the recommendation from the county probation department, which noted that, "When compared to other crimes of similar nature" the Turner case "may be considered less serious due to [his] level of intoxication." Critics immediately pounced and alleged Persky went soft because of his commonalities with the defendant. Like Turner, Persky was also a Stanford athlete. (He played lacrosse.)

Still, the case may have faded from the spotlight had it not been for the emotionally searing letter the victim read to Turner at sentencing. Within days, it went viral on the internet.

"You don't know me, but you've been inside me, and that's why we're here today," it began.

"You made me a victim. In newspapers my name was 'unconscious intoxicated woman,' 10 syllables, and nothing more than that. For a while, I believed that that was all I was."

Critics of Persky, who has been on the bench since 2003, find it ironic that his judicial background also included work as a sex crimes prosecutor. In other words, he helped incarcerate people like Turner, 22, who is now living near Dayton, Ohio, and required to register annually for life as a sex offender. That's a penalty so burdensome that if Turner were to have children someday, he wouldn't be able to get near their school. Those who defend Persky often point to this fact. Though unable to speak about the case because it is under appeal, Persky has not indicated he would have done anything differently.

"Someday you may be on the right side of the law, and the wrong side of public opinion, and when you step into a courtroom before a judge, you will expect, you will request, you will demand a judge who will follow the rule of law," he said.

Critics and an unlikely ally

The recall campaign has been led by Stanford Law professor Michelle Dauber, a family friend of the victim. Relentless in attacking the judge and the sentence, her group has raised $1.2 million to fund the effort.

"Voters are entitled to hold him [Persky] accountable for how he exercises his discretion," she said in an interview."

Though her effort began long before #MeToo became a hashtag and a movement, Dauber views the case as an anchor point.

"I think Emily Doe's victim impact statement in many ways really serves as a manifesto for the #MeToo movement. I think that it predates it. In some ways it helped to launch it. I think that's because she put into words the feelings that many victims of sexual assault have had for so many generations."

Bolstering Dauber's efforts, The Mercury News, the local newspaper here, endorsed the recall.

"Voters need to stand up and make a statement on behalf of women and men about the seriousness of sexual assault," it said in an editorial.

"Persky's sentence failed to do so to an extent that he never will again be able to serve as a respected, effective judge. He should be recalled."

To be sure, both sides have distinguished names and organizations backing them.

Here's who's pushing the recall

Perksy, however, has found an unlikely ally in Santa Clara County District Attorney Jeff Rosen whose prosecutors pushed for a stronger sentence. Rosen could have stayed on the sidelines; instead he is actively speaking out, appearing at a news conference on Wednesday with Perksy.

"To recall a judge for one bad decision is something that would have dramatically negative effects throughout our criminal justice system, " he said.

Here's who wants the judge to stay

Persky also got a green light from the Commission on Judicial Performance, an independent state agency, which found no evidence of bias or misconduct with his rulings.

Dauber dismissed the report as "a one-sided, closed-door proceeding."

The feelings on both sides of the recall are so strong that some are worried about the fallout of endorsing a particular side. Persky tells a story about how he asked one of his longtime friends to put up a yard sign to show support. When the man hedged, Persky said he realized how divisive the issue had become.

"He didn't want to wonder, 'What will my neighbors think? What will people think about me? What conclusions will they draw about my character if I put this lawn sign on my lawn? Will they still like me?'" Persky said.

Asked later whether the friend had eventually put up the sign, Perksy replied "not yet," but that he was still hopeful he would. There isn't much time left to ponder.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 448268

Reported Deaths: 6013
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin931011480
Ramsey40016739
Dakota33072340
Anoka30999364
Washington20164228
Stearns17871187
St. Louis13690241
Scott1195496
Wright11614104
Olmsted1048475
Sherburne821365
Carver694836
Clay653280
Rice606868
Kandiyohi554371
Blue Earth541033
Crow Wing482774
Otter Tail457167
Chisago452732
Benton420186
Winona389646
Douglas374166
Nobles370846
Mower365529
Goodhue347958
Polk328658
McLeod325345
Morrison311744
Beltrami310347
Lyon302236
Becker284939
Itasca284543
Isanti282841
Carlton280043
Steele27379
Pine266713
Freeborn245321
Todd231730
Nicollet224636
Brown215134
Mille Lacs214246
Le Sueur210015
Cass207623
Meeker199733
Waseca189316
Wabasha17083
Martin170026
Roseau165416
Hubbard149338
Redwood139727
Renville137539
Houston135913
Dodge13474
Chippewa131332
Cottonwood127218
Fillmore12355
Wadena120116
Rock110212
Sibley10857
Aitkin108433
Watonwan10668
Faribault105916
Pennington99215
Kanabec97818
Pipestone94423
Yellow Medicine93714
Murray8815
Jackson85610
Swift83418
Pope7385
Marshall70215
Stevens7018
Clearwater68514
Lac qui Parle65716
Lake63715
Wilkin6259
Koochiching59610
Lincoln4841
Big Stone4573
Unassigned43768
Grant4298
Norman4248
Mahnomen4107
Kittson37219
Red Lake3174
Traverse2503
Lake of the Woods1951
Cook1140

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 305606

Reported Deaths: 4278
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk45754449
Linn17795275
Scott15444163
Black Hawk13773236
Woodbury13016175
Johnson1211749
Dubuque11387150
Pottawattamie8992112
Dallas888671
Story869434
Webster469771
Cerro Gordo466768
Sioux455157
Clinton450361
Warren443938
Marshall427761
Buena Vista393429
Muscatine390477
Des Moines381841
Plymouth350368
Wapello344198
Jasper321959
Lee317130
Marion304952
Jones271349
Henry264330
Carroll255434
Bremer245048
Crawford231022
Boone218417
Washington217632
Benton209444
Mahaska193136
Jackson192031
Tama187757
Dickinson186026
Delaware173736
Kossuth173644
Clay168820
Wright164824
Fayette162322
Hamilton160029
Buchanan159923
Winneshiek155719
Harrison155162
Hardin154729
Cedar153219
Clayton151448
Butler148224
Page144715
Floyd139636
Cherokee139027
Mills136416
Lyon135332
Poweshiek132724
Hancock130224
Allamakee127928
Iowa125422
Calhoun12279
Grundy121226
Jefferson120724
Madison12039
Winnebago119429
Mitchell116234
Louisa115030
Cass113341
Chickasaw111612
Sac111215
Emmet110831
Appanoose110538
Union108822
Humboldt105519
Guthrie103024
Shelby102926
Franklin102418
Unassigned9310
Palo Alto9079
Montgomery85622
Keokuk85026
Howard84219
Monroe81218
Clarke7957
Pocahontas77611
Ida74630
Greene6927
Davis69121
Adair68820
Lucas6508
Monona64016
Osceola6409
Worth6113
Taylor5949
Fremont5126
Van Buren49712
Decatur4894
Ringgold4389
Audubon4158
Wayne41421
Adams2963
Rochester/St. Mary'S
Clear
34° wxIcon
Hi: 36° Lo: -1°
Feels Like: 23°
Mason City
Clear
36° wxIcon
Hi: 38° Lo: 1°
Feels Like: 24°
Albert Lea
Partly Cloudy
36° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 0°
Feels Like: 26°
Austin
Clear
36° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: -1°
Feels Like: 25°
Charles City
Partly Cloudy
36° wxIcon
Hi: 37° Lo: 1°
Feels Like: 24°
A roller coaster of temperatures
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events