STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Pedestrian killed in accident involving self-driving Uber

An Arizona woman has died after being struck by a self-driving Uber in Tempe, Arizona. This is the first known fatality of an accident involving a self-driving car.

Posted: Mar 21, 2018 2:27 PM
Updated: Mar 21, 2018 2:40 PM

A pedestrian is killed by a car roughly every 90 minutes in the United States. And until this week, all of those drivers were human.

Then 49-year-old Elaine Herzberg was struck and killed by a self-driving Uber in Tempe, Arizona on Sunday night.

But self-driving cars don't pose any more of a risk to pedestrians, bicyclists or other cars than cars piloted by humans.

Self-driving cars have already been put through millions of miles of road tests, and experts say that the technology clearly has the potential to be safer than human drivers. Indeed it could save a huge number of lives if or when it becomes widely adopted.

There were an estimated 40,000 traffic fatalities on US roads last year, according to the National Safety Council, and more than 90% of them were caused by human error.

"Human drivers aren't that safe," said Lionel Robert, a professor at the Robots Institute at the University of Michigan. He said the goal is not to make self-driving cars as safe as human drivers. "We want self-driving cars to be safer," he said.

Related: Uber's self-driving car fatality draws national scrutiny

In difficult conditions, such as limited visibility or on bad roads, an experienced human driver may have an edge over self-driving cars using today's technology, said Bart Selman, professor of computer science at Cornell University. But he expects that self-driving cars will eventually be much safer.

"They look around the car 360 degrees. They're able to take in way more information than a human driver and they don't get distracted," said Selman.

Self-driving cars are actually better than humans at obeying traffic laws. They don't drive drive too fast. They don't text and drive. They don't drive drunk. They don't fall asleep and drift into oncoming traffic.

That alone makes them safer drivers than humans, said Mike Ramsey, director of research at Gartner.

Selman and Robert both say that Sunday's accident, as tragic as it was, will help improve self-driving safety. By studying what happened, developers can improve the technology used to avoid pedestrians.

"You can make all the predictions you want, but you learn from actual experience," said Robert. "You need systems to be tested out on the road."

Related: Self-driving car accidents will keep happening. We need to learn from them

Self-driving cars are very good at detecting and avoiding obstacles, Selman said. But teaching a car to anticipate that a pedestrian might step in front of it is still one of the most difficult things to do, according to the experts.

Uber has put testing its self-driving cars on hold while the investigation is completed, and Toyota also halted road tests of autonomous cars.

The cause of the accident Sunday has yet to be determined by police. The National Transportation Safety Board, which typically investigates plane crashes and train accidents but not car crashes, is also investigating.

"No one ever said all accidents are preventable," said Ramsey. "Nevertheless, it raises questions. We need to make sure these systems are working correctly."

--CNN's Peter Valdes-Dapena and Matt McFarland contributed to this story.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 581335

Reported Deaths: 7267
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin1206301710
Ramsey50221865
Dakota44921441
Anoka40688432
Washington26275278
Stearns21864220
St. Louis17475302
Scott16941123
Wright15685135
Olmsted1308297
Sherburne1136784
Carver1029545
Clay806892
Rice7920104
Blue Earth736041
Crow Wing650687
Kandiyohi646681
Chisago579751
Otter Tail565877
Benton558897
Goodhue469972
Mower459432
Douglas458774
Winona447350
McLeod416558
Itasca416253
Morrison412660
Isanti407062
Nobles406348
Beltrami386258
Steele379115
Polk378567
Becker374049
Lyon356850
Carlton340152
Freeborn338929
Pine323321
Nicollet320243
Brown302740
Mille Lacs297252
Le Sueur284722
Todd277131
Cass264828
Meeker249638
Waseca234821
Martin227131
Roseau204519
Wabasha20293
Hubbard182941
Dodge18073
Renville177543
Redwood170636
Houston166915
Cottonwood161921
Fillmore153710
Pennington153219
Wadena152121
Chippewa151238
Faribault149419
Kanabec141824
Sibley140610
Aitkin132836
Watonwan12979
Rock126819
Jackson120911
Pipestone113626
Yellow Medicine113420
Pope10766
Murray10529
Swift103818
Stevens88011
Marshall87417
Clearwater85416
Koochiching80914
Lake80519
Wilkin79612
Lac qui Parle74822
Big Stone5924
Lincoln5723
Grant5638
Mahnomen5408
Norman5369
Unassigned51793
Kittson48222
Red Lake3947
Traverse3675
Lake of the Woods3173
Cook1550

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 364143

Reported Deaths: 5900
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk57127619
Linn20675333
Scott19714239
Black Hawk15734307
Woodbury15078228
Johnson1438283
Dubuque13308207
Dallas1108797
Pottawattamie11021166
Story1052948
Warren571488
Clinton550792
Cerro Gordo534689
Sioux511674
Webster510892
Marshall480775
Muscatine472999
Des Moines450366
Wapello4278122
Buena Vista423940
Jasper412770
Plymouth399979
Lee371955
Marion360075
Jones296457
Henry290237
Carroll284352
Bremer282360
Crawford264140
Boone262334
Benton254955
Washington252250
Dickinson247343
Mahaska228850
Jackson220642
Clay214625
Kossuth214564
Tama208871
Delaware208040
Winneshiek196333
Page191921
Buchanan190331
Cedar188623
Hardin184443
Fayette184341
Wright183136
Harrison179073
Hamilton178949
Clayton168456
Butler163734
Mills161321
Madison159719
Floyd159442
Cherokee158338
Lyon157541
Poweshiek154533
Allamakee150251
Iowa147924
Hancock146534
Winnebago140631
Cass137654
Grundy136032
Calhoun135313
Emmet133040
Jefferson132135
Shelby130337
Sac129819
Appanoose127847
Louisa127849
Union127332
Mitchell125642
Chickasaw123515
Guthrie120629
Humboldt118726
Franklin116221
Palo Alto112123
Howard104122
Montgomery102437
Unassigned9990
Clarke99324
Keokuk95431
Monroe95028
Ida90234
Adair86032
Pocahontas85422
Monona82830
Davis81324
Osceola77716
Greene77310
Lucas76823
Worth7338
Taylor65612
Fremont6209
Decatur6059
Van Buren55618
Ringgold54424
Wayne53123
Audubon5009
Adams3374
Rochester
Cloudy
44° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 44°
Mason City
Cloudy
45° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 38°
Albert Lea
Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 58° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 38°
Austin
Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 59° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 38°
Charles City
Cloudy
° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: °
Rain for Wednesday afternoon
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events