Hong Kong's top court strikes down Joshua Wong prison sentence

Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Joshua Wong scored a major legal victory Tuesday, as the city's top court threw out ...

Posted: Feb 6, 2018 12:11 PM
Updated: Feb 6, 2018 12:12 PM

Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Joshua Wong scored a major legal victory Tuesday, as the city's top court threw out the prison sentences handed to him and two other leaders of the 2014 Umbrella Movement protests.

In August, Wong, Nathan Law and Alex Chow were convicted to between six and eight months in prison for public order offenses stemming from the protests, which shut down parts of the city for several months.

Court endorsed a stricter standard for future protests which could result in more prison sentences

Wong said the "road ahead is still very difficult" for the city's pro-democracy movement

They were originally sentenced to community service and suspended sentences, but an appeals court controversially upgraded that to prison time. Tuesday's decision quashes their prison sentences and reinstates the initial ruling.

While the Court of Final Appeal (CFA) endorsed a higher standard for public order offenses put forward by the Court of Appeal, it said the judges were wrong to apply that standard retroactively to Wong, Law and Chow's case.

However, the city's top court warned that in future, public order offenders, even those stemming from civil disobedience, would be dealt with strictly and could involve prison terms.

Nor is Tuesday's win the end for Wong. He's currently out on bail appealing a separate conviction, for contempt of court, also stemming from the 2014 protests.

"I would not say this is a win and there is no reason for us to celebrate. What we are up against is the court taking a very narrow definition of non-violent civil disobedience actions," said Wong.

"The road ahead is still very difficult."

Legal overload

Tuesday's case was one of dozens brought against protesters and pro-democracy politicians since the 2014 demonstrations, which analysts say are designed to sap morale and dissuade other young people from taking to the streets.

In the past year or so, pro-democracy politicians have been disqualified from office, had numerous court cases brought against them, and prospective candidates have been barred from standing in elections to the city's parliament.

Last month, Agnes Chow, a member of Wong and Law's political party, Demosisto, had her application to run in an upcoming by-election denied on the grounds that the party's platform advocates for Hong Kongers to be allowed to decide on their own future, including voting on a potential break from China.

In 2016 several candidates advocating for Hong Kong independence were also barred from running for office -- on the grounds that this is contrary to the city's constitutional principles as a Special Administrative Region of China.

In a statement, a group of senior Hong Kong lawyers said the decision to bar Chow was "unreasonable, unlawful and unconstitutional."

"Disqualification of candidates with certain political opinion or affiliation frustrates the core purpose of an open and fair election, which is to guarantee the free expression of the will of the electors," the statement said.

The move was also widely denounced by international observers. A European Union spokeswoman said it "risks diminishing Hong Kong's international reputation as a free and open society" and was in contravention of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which Hong Kong is a signatory.

Speaking to reporters following the decision however, Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam said "any suggestion of Hong Kong independence or democratic self-determination ... deviates from the important basic principle of 'one country, two systems'," under which the city is governed.

Nobel nomination

Lam had denounced international criticism of the Chow decision as interference in Hong Kong's internal affairs, a point she returned to this month after several US lawmakers nominated Wong, Law and Chow for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.

"This nomination could not be more timely as Hong Kong's long-cherished autonomy continues to erode, and Umbrella Movement leaders face reprisals simply for espousing basic human rights and freedoms," said Senator Marco Rubio in statement. "Joshua Wong and his fellow pro-democracy advocates have been unflinching in their peaceful and principled commitment to a free and prosperous Hong Kong."

The statement referenced the death last year of jailed Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo, the first Nobel Peace Prize laureate to die in state custody since Carl von Ossietzky in Nazi Germany in 1938.

In a joint statement, the three said they were honored to receive the nomination, adding "at this critical juncture, we need to join hands with the international community and together defend Hong Kong as a bridgehead for democratic movements."

Lam however said the move was "regrettable" and accused the US lawmakers of seeking "political intervention" in Hong Kong's affairs.

In a statement, China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said "Hong Kong's affairs are China's domestic affairs, and China firmly objects to anyone intervening through any means."

Only politicians, former laureates, and certain civil society groups can nominate people or institutions for the Nobel Peace Prize.

While the award has been widely criticized in the past from multiple political quarters, it still carries huge international cache.

China was so incensed with Liu's win that it cut trade with Norway, hurting the country's economy, and similar reaction could be expected were Wong, Law and Chow to win.

Minnesota Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 604052

Reported Deaths: 7616
CountyCasesDeaths
Hennepin1248161773
Ramsey52466895
Dakota46797470
Anoka42724458
Washington27406291
Stearns22552224
St. Louis18134312
Scott17544135
Wright16405148
Olmsted13390102
Sherburne1200195
Carver1066148
Clay825692
Rice8187110
Blue Earth762443
Crow Wing681494
Kandiyohi667585
Chisago619652
Otter Tail585684
Benton582998
Goodhue483474
Douglas475381
Mower470733
Winona461151
Itasca459263
Isanti439964
McLeod430161
Morrison424362
Nobles407950
Beltrami407561
Steele397616
Polk389072
Becker386555
Lyon363853
Carlton352756
Freeborn346932
Pine335023
Nicollet331045
Mille Lacs311454
Brown307840
Le Sueur297225
Cass286032
Todd285632
Meeker263142
Waseca238023
Martin235032
Roseau211021
Wabasha20783
Hubbard196241
Dodge18773
Renville182446
Redwood176338
Houston174616
Cottonwood167124
Wadena162823
Fillmore157410
Faribault154319
Chippewa153938
Pennington153820
Kanabec146828
Sibley146810
Aitkin138737
Watonwan13579
Rock128719
Jackson122612
Pipestone116626
Yellow Medicine114920
Pope11296
Murray107010
Swift106918
Koochiching95117
Stevens92411
Clearwater89116
Marshall88817
Lake83120
Wilkin83112
Lac qui Parle75622
Big Stone6044
Grant5938
Lincoln5843
Mahnomen5669
Norman5479
Kittson49022
Unassigned48093
Red Lake4017
Traverse3765
Lake of the Woods3453
Cook1720

Iowa Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 370840

Reported Deaths: 6048
CountyCasesDeaths
Polk58221639
Linn21202339
Scott20303247
Black Hawk16106312
Woodbury15237230
Johnson1461485
Dubuque13505211
Dallas1128899
Pottawattamie11219174
Story1071148
Warren583791
Clinton561493
Cerro Gordo553693
Sioux516974
Webster515194
Muscatine4878106
Marshall486576
Des Moines467271
Wapello4337122
Buena Vista426940
Jasper420972
Plymouth402881
Lee382356
Marion366076
Jones300857
Henry294237
Bremer288161
Carroll286752
Boone268434
Crawford268240
Benton259655
Washington256951
Dickinson249444
Mahaska232352
Jackson225242
Clay216627
Kossuth216166
Tama211871
Delaware210943
Winneshiek198135
Page194522
Buchanan193433
Cedar192223
Hardin187544
Fayette186543
Wright185840
Hamilton181851
Harrison180073
Clayton171057
Butler166135
Madison164619
Mills163724
Floyd163242
Cherokee159438
Lyon158841
Poweshiek157036
Allamakee152752
Hancock150234
Iowa149824
Winnebago144431
Cass139155
Calhoun138913
Grundy137133
Emmet135841
Jefferson133535
Shelby131537
Sac130920
Union129935
Louisa129649
Appanoose129049
Mitchell126643
Chickasaw124717
Franklin123323
Guthrie123132
Humboldt119526
Palo Alto113523
Howard104922
Montgomery103638
Clarke100924
Keokuk96432
Monroe96230
Unassigned9540
Ida91535
Adair87332
Pocahontas85822
Davis85225
Monona82931
Osceola78916
Greene78011
Lucas77923
Worth7598
Taylor66812
Fremont6269
Decatur6169
Ringgold56324
Van Buren56318
Wayne54423
Audubon53511
Adams3444
Rochester
Clear
91° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 91°
Mason City
Clear
98° wxIcon
Hi: 100° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 97°
Albert Lea
Partly Cloudy
91° wxIcon
Hi: 94° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 94°
Austin
Partly Cloudy
95° wxIcon
Hi: 96° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 96°
Charles City
Partly Cloudy
91° wxIcon
Hi: 95° Lo: 67°
Feels Like: 94°
Strong thunderstorms possible on Thursday
KIMT Radar
KIMT Eye in the sky

Community Events